I have heard of cases where engineers were unable to synchronize a generator with the grid. The generators and the equipments were reported to be in excellent condition and they had the latest safety relays etc. The IEEE 1547 standard states for synchronization - voltage - ± 5% of base V Phase - ± 5 degrees Frequency - For a 60 Hz system ? 59.3 Hz to 60.5 Hz (How much for a 50 Hz system?)
If all the above conditions are met, am I correct in assuming that synchronization is possible? What is the generator is working perfectly and it is the grid is unstable? Is this possible? In such instances, how would you check the grid? How can this be corrected, assuming the grid is unstable? How can synchronization be possible?
------------------------- The phase angle has to be pretty close to sync the generator to the grid. And to get that, you have to have pretty fine control of the unit's output frequency. Not just keep it within 5%. If the unit frequency stays within even 59.9 and 60.1, but can't be kept stable and wanders back and forth between those values, synchronizing should probably not be attempted.
Determining *which* is the unstable frequency is as simple as placing an accurate meter on each and watching for a couple of minutes. Or if you want to get really fancy, hook up a strip-chart recorder capable of monitoring the frequency of both the unit and the bus (suitable transducers on each side of the sync-metering circuits should work).
I'd bet 'dollars to doughnuts' that its the governor on the unit and not the grid that is unstable. Unless you're talking a tiny, private 'grid'.
One other thing that people sometimes forget (to their dismay), is that polyphase equipment must also have the same phase rotation. This has to be checked in new installations and after disconnecting equipment/wiring. The results of having reversed phase rotation doesn't show up on conventional metering and can be truly disasterous if not corrected before syncing to the grid the first time.
daestrom