Subject
- Posted on
November 20, 2006, 2:34 am
Hi,
Recently I read an article or saw a television show describing the
contrast between "old legos" and "new legos". The point of the article
was that in the good old days lego kits were full of generic, highly
interchangeable bricks that could be used to make anything you could
imagine. But nowadays the newer lego kits are full of bricks of more
limited intercompatibility, bricks which are mainly designed to let you
construct the single, elaborate, predefined centerpiece pictured on the
box (such a spaceship, or a car).
The article argued this change was a bad thing, since it required less
imagination from people using legos. I have two questions for the lego
mavens here.
Simple Question: Where on Earth did I read this article (or TV piece)?
I can't remember where I ran into the idea, but it took root in my
mind. I'd like to revisit it. It may have been on the BBC, but I'm
really not sure.
Deeper Question: Is this true? Is this the common wisdom, or a common
complaint, among lego afficianados? Have lego kits changed from the
good old days, so that now a given kit can produce a smaller number of
interesting results? If this is for real, what kits old and new stand
out as representative examples of this trend?
I'm much obliged for all your opinions and pointers.
Alexis
Recently I read an article or saw a television show describing the
contrast between "old legos" and "new legos". The point of the article
was that in the good old days lego kits were full of generic, highly
interchangeable bricks that could be used to make anything you could
imagine. But nowadays the newer lego kits are full of bricks of more
limited intercompatibility, bricks which are mainly designed to let you
construct the single, elaborate, predefined centerpiece pictured on the
box (such a spaceship, or a car).
The article argued this change was a bad thing, since it required less
imagination from people using legos. I have two questions for the lego
mavens here.
Simple Question: Where on Earth did I read this article (or TV piece)?
I can't remember where I ran into the idea, but it took root in my
mind. I'd like to revisit it. It may have been on the BBC, but I'm
really not sure.
Deeper Question: Is this true? Is this the common wisdom, or a common
complaint, among lego afficianados? Have lego kits changed from the
good old days, so that now a given kit can produce a smaller number of
interesting results? If this is for real, what kits old and new stand
out as representative examples of this trend?
I'm much obliged for all your opinions and pointers.
Alexis
Re: good old legos (generic) vs bad new legos (kit-based)
curvy and round now, Lots more curved
bricks etc.
I think kids now prefer something that looks good, rather than using the parts
to build something else. Lack of patience
is probably the reason for this.
Technic is probably the worst, I don't particularly like the Smooth Technic
Beams they use now.
Re: good old legos (generic) vs bad new legos (kit-based)
Huh. I was going to say Technic is in some sense the best, since the
"studless" system works perfectly well with the "studded" system, and
there are a lot of things I can do with a studless construction that
there's just no way to do with conventional brick-and-plate.
To the original question, yes, there do seem to be a lot more
specialized, "one use only" parts. But in some sense I think these have
*decreased* in the past couple years. Also, in some sense the biggest
offender on this point, Bionicle, is also one of LEGO's best sellers,
so there may be a good economic point to more "specialized" parts. All
that said, I don't find the amount of creativity reduced at all - to
the contrary, actually. I keep tossing parts that are "worthless" to my
9-year-old son, who finds amazing uses for them very different than
their "intended" use. Perhaps it's not the product that's lacking
imagination and flexibility, but our older generation mindset.
--
Brian Davis
Re: good old legos (generic) vs bad new legos (kit-based)
years. I like the technic stuff, but when they moved into "this is the
custom molded hood/nosecone/arm/whatever", I stopped buying most of the
kits. Now I tend to weatch out for the sales on the "stareter" type sets, or
just buy bulk brick through the parts stores...
-_JD
Re: good old legos (generic) vs bad new legos (kit-based)
Anyone who thinks the newer pieces engender less creativity hasn't been to
BrickFest in recent years. I am amazed at how these "more limited
intercompatibility" pieces are used in models. I think these newer pieces call
forth more imagination and creativity.
--
Ken Rice -=:=- kennrice (AT) erols (DOT) com
http://users.erols.com/kennrice - Lego Compatible Flex Track,
Civil War Round Table of DC & Concentration Camp made of Lego bricks
http://members.tripod.com/~kennrice
Maps of Ultima 7 Parts 1 & 2, Prophecy of the Shadow, Savage Empire,
Crusaders of Dark Savant & Others.
Re: good old legos (generic) vs bad new legos (kit-based)
and with bionicle i have just been collecting the connector and chop
the balls leaving a bit of xrod to insert into a x hole 1x2for a cheap
and dirty shoulder or hip
most of the new pieces have caused me to get lazy like with the click
hinge plates and bricks they sure work alot better than the old 2 and 3
finger hinges
they still have bulk tubs but the gap between bulk tubs and models has
really increased since the late 80s
my most hated technic piece is the 2791 and 2792 tilt wheel stering
shouldnt be made so easy i prefered them using the universal joint and
rack and pinion stering
of course with that kind of ludite mentality we would still be using
the gears of the old samsonite years
i invented my own differential years ago using a 40 drilled out plates
and bricks and 3 crown gears it was pretty big but it worked
i could forgive winshields and right angle brackets but boat hulls and
castle walls take the challenge away
Site Timeline
- » Short movie of Lego Duplo bunny available online?
- — Next thread in » Using Lego and compatible building blocks
-

- » The ultimate Batman set...
- — Previous thread in » Using Lego and compatible building blocks
-

- » Faroese landscape (work in progress)
- — Newest thread in » Using Lego and compatible building blocks
-

- » Seagulls (minifig scale)
- — Last Updated thread in » Using Lego and compatible building blocks
-

- » Bending 1/8 inch thick 7075-T6 aluminum
- — The site's Newest Thread. Posted in » General Metalworking
-









