Subject
- Posted on
NXT compatible with RCX?
- 02-04-2006
February 4, 2006, 12:03 pm
My child has saved his allowance to buy a Mindstorm set, but now we see that
there is a new version on the way. Does anyone here know if the old stuff
will be able to work with the new stuff? Seems like it should, backward
compatablity being the standard, but I don't want to advise him until I know
for sure.
IOW, if we buy one now, then want more sets later, will we have to have
multiple transmitters, software and differently written instructions for
each type of brick?
--
Bill DeWitt
there is a new version on the way. Does anyone here know if the old stuff
will be able to work with the new stuff? Seems like it should, backward
compatablity being the standard, but I don't want to advise him until I know
for sure.
IOW, if we buy one now, then want more sets later, will we have to have
multiple transmitters, software and differently written instructions for
each type of brick?
--
Bill DeWitt
Re: NXT compatible with RCX?
NXT: http://legoeducation.typepad.com/blog/transition/index.html
Yes, each type of brick will have different software etc. (hough I read
that NQC will be usable on both).
I would wait until the NXT comes out to buy a MindStorms set now,
especially since Lego has stopped manufacturing the original sets
anyway, so you can only get them second hand.
Bill DeWitt wrote:
Re: NXT compatible with RCX?
subject.
If we end up getting a used one while waiting for the new one, will the
lessons he learns be directly applicable to the new one. IOW, is the
programming language the same, will there be the same method of forming
loops and conditional statements?
--
Bill DeWitt
The one function that TV news performs very well is that, when there is
no news, we give it to you with the same emphasis as if there were.
David Brinkley (b. 1920) American TV journalist
Re: NXT compatible with RCX?
Thanks Orkie. I found a demo page for Robolab and the demo was totally
graphical, do you know if you can get past that into the written language?
--
Bill DeWitt
Everybody is a nice guy, underneath it all. What we become when the
world is through messing us over is something else. - Hagbard Celine
Re: NXT compatible with RCX?
Lego only has only made one non-graphical programming tool as far as I'm
aware and that is MindScript, but I wouldn't recommend it. If you want a
decent text based programming language which uses the official firmware,
take a look at NQC: http://bricxcc.sourceforge.net/nqc/
It is free, C-like and very powerful. Most people who use MindStorms use
it now since all the official programming environments are too limited.
Furthermore, the author has announced that they will be porting it to
the NXT meaning that any existing programs should run with little or no
modification.
Hope that helps.
PS: A good IDE for NQC can be found here:
http://bricxcc.sourceforge.net/ . It saves you having to use the command
prompt to compile all your programs as well as allowing you to remotely
read raw sensor values etc.
Re: NXT compatible with RCX?
I have not had more than a preliminary look at both, but I was a little
concerned that leJOS did not seem "done" yet, in that routines for some
hardware were still being developed. Was my first impression from their home
page wrong?
I did like the idea, whether deserved or not, that while learning leJOS
we would also be getting some introduction to JAVA. Is this a reasonable
interpretation of their web page info? Their FAQ page (
http://lejos.sourceforge.net/faq.html ) is not working for me.
I won't have time to actually take a closer look at all this stuff until
the weekend, so I appreciate any conversation and opinions. Of course... I
don't even have the mindstorm in my hand yet.
--
Bill DeWitt
The only Zen you find on the tops of mountains is the Zen you bring up
there. - Robert M. Pirsig
Site Timeline
- » Lego mindstorms - programs
- — Next thread in » Lego Mindstorms Discussions
-

- » Looking for Mindstorms 2.0 Robotic Arm Instructions
- — Previous thread in » Lego Mindstorms Discussions
-

- » RCX firmware download problem
- — Newest thread in » Lego Mindstorms Discussions
-

- » LEGO Mindstorms NXT 2.0 Alpha Rex with Visual Basic Programming Interface
- — Last Updated thread in » Lego Mindstorms Discussions
-

- » Bending 1/8 inch thick 7075-T6 aluminum
- — The site's Newest Thread. Posted in » General Metalworking
-

- » Rysunek techniczny-pytania
- — The site's Last Updated Thread. Posted in » Engineering Science (Polish)
-









