Hi all.
For various reasons, we have dumped Soildworks where I work (well, technically we've just stopped paying subscription), and are looking at changing CAD packages. We are on SW2004, looking at the base package of the latest Wildfire.
From what I've seen it looks pretty good, and I don't see anything that we currently do in SW that can't be done in ProE. Obviously some methods, etc will need to change, but I can deal with that.I have seen two demos, one canned web-demo, and one where a ProE guy came in and showed us some things. It was refreshing to see things work not-quite-as-expected.*
So, here's what I'd like to know:
-Are there any particular bugs to look out for (please see below for what kind of parts we make here)? Anything killer or that I wouldn't know to ask to see, yet is quite a pain to actual users?**
-How stable is it?
-Any recommended hardware beyond what PTC recommends/certifies? Real-world memory size, etc.
-How is ProE with large assemblies (700-1500 parts/sub-assys)? Stability, speed, etc.
-What is creating drawings like?
-Anything else I should look for in particular? ie: Questions for reseller, etc.
What we do here: Nearly all of our parts are simple blocks of steel with holes and cuts. There's no surfacing or complex geometry. There are a few simple tubes (bent tubing) and sheet metal parts. Nothing complex. So I'm not going to be pushing the modelling aspects of ProE anywhere near it's limits.
We have a fair number of parts with configurations in SW, and from what I've seen I'd likely make good use of the parent->child parts (similar to SW's base part--sorry, I don't know what ProE actually calls it). These are either one casting (or one blank part) to make several finished parts, which are indential except for one or two features. Any practical limits to this? My application would likely: Base_part->Intermediate_part--->All_the_finished_parts. Changes in Base_part do propagate to All_the_finished_parts, correct?
So basically, I want to know how good this thing actually is. Input from anyone who's used both would be really helpful.
Thanks, John
- Converting an AutoCAD drawing into a ProE model-->Open the model to edit a sketch and change dimensions--->While trying to add reference dimensions, the dim would place in the middle of screen, so we all thought it wasn't actually placing the dimension. Took a while to realize that.
** SW has a pretty bug where if you define a cut as "Offset from surface" the dim appears (in the model and in the drawing) as from the selected surface to the middle of empty space! This is something I wouldn't think to ask a salesman (and they likely wouldn't show me), but which becomes a real PITA when you have guys from the shop coming up to you and asking "WTF is up with this drawing?!"