Carbon arc -- now what?

Anybody have experience with a carbon-arc torch?

Okay, I decided to take the time to play a little bit, and I've always wanted to see what a carbon-arc torch could do. The local welding shop doesn't have the electrodes, nor do I have a torch, but I decided to start by experimenting with the carbon rods out of a couple of old D-size batteries.

I extracted the carbon rods, wiped them clean, dressed one end of one of them to a blunt cone. Haven't rigged up anything to hold two rods like a true carbon arc torch, but thought maybe I could just put a rod into the regular electrode holder and strike an arc. So I did. I could hold an arc at about 85 amps, and the arc was definitely melting the 1/4" scrap metal directly under the arc. But now I have some questions:

1) I noticed some sort of liquid coming out of the carbon rod as soon as it began to heat up -- anybody got any ideas what this was? Some acid from the battery, maybe? After a couple of tries, it seemed to stop oozing any liquid.

2) The carbon electrode got very very hot very quickly -- it was glowing bright red within 30 seconds or less. Also, it seems to be consumed more quickly than I expected, though much less quickly than a welding electrode. Is this consistent with what would happen with a "real" carbon arc electrode? Can it be run red-hot for an extended period of time, or does this indicate that I'm putting too much current through? (These rods are around 5/16" diameter.)

3) How much difference would it make to have two carbon electrodes rather than just the one? From the one electrode I got a lot of heat but in a very small area -- it would be hard to use it for, say, heating something up to bend it, which is what I understood you could do with a carbon-arc torch. OTOH, I noticed quite a bit of a flare or flame out to the side -- is this what you use when you have the carbon arc going from one electrode to the other?

Any insights, suggestions, comments are welcome. Thanks!

Andy

Reply to
Andrew H. Wakefield
Loading thread data ...
1) Liquid is probably left over from it's duty as a battery. 2) IIRC, a 'D' cell carbon is around 1/4". I run my carbon arc torch with 3/8" copper coated carbons at around 70 to 80 amps. I think you were running yours pretty hot, especially with no copper to conduct the eletricity down to the arc area. 3) With two carbons you get an arc "flame" that is quite wide. Great for heating, not particulary useable for welding. It does have a quirk that if you get too close, the arc with quit jumping between the two carbons and start hopping from carbon to work and off to the other carbon.

I use mine for brazing when I have a large object. Lots of heat, fairly gentle flame, doesn't burn the brazing rod. I bought it years ago when I didn't do enough work to justify a O/A set up with the retal fees on the tanks.

I've never tried welding, I might try a one carbon version as an experiment.

The old timers used to deal with stuck truck lug nuts us> Anybody have experience with a carbon-arc torch?

Reply to
RoyJ

That's what I'm thinking ...

Aha--I guess I need to dial it down. I tried to hold an arc at 75 amps but couldn't ... but didn't try too hard, and didn't have the two carbons. How quickly do your electrodes consume? And is the end cone-shaped?

Yeah, that's the kind of thing I'd like to be able to do. I hadn't thought about trying to weld with it, since I would normally just use a stick electrode :)

Reply to
Andrew H. Wakefield

Carbon rods are usually copper coated and used with compressed air in "arc-air" gouging of defective welds. Compressed air forces the molten steel away from the arc, the process makes short work of shifting large amounts of steel and makes a hell of a racket.

formatting link

Reply to
mb

Yes, I know about the air gouging system; what I'm referring to is somewhat different. Apparently it used to be quite common to have a carbon-arc torch to go with your buzz box for heating metal, but it's hard to find them now, or at least I haven't found anyone locally who sells them. I think the gouges may be more commonly available now than the torches.

Andy

Reply to
Andrew H. Wakefield

Reply to
RoyJ

I have a couple of them around. Work good for brazing when you know how to adjust them. Also using one electrode you can do spot welds on sheet metal easily. I use the copper covered rods and have no problems. Eastwood still sells a spotweld gun that uses carbon arc electrodes. They work pretty good if you cannot get to the rear of a panel with a tong style unit.

To use a carbon arc torch you use two electrodes and adjust the tip angle to adjust the "flame". The sharper the angle the farther out the arc will reach and put more heat onto the work. The shallower the angle the lower the heat onto the part. One word of warning though the arc flash will cook you worse than standard arc welding and it reflects a lot of heat back. Also don't forget that you have both sides of the circuit in the torch, set it down CAREFULLY.

formatting link
for a quick look at a non quick adjust unit. Mine can be adjusted as you use it by sliding the electrodes closer or farther as you work.

Reply to
Steve W.

I have a carbon arc torch somewhere around here that I bought at Montgomery Wards, back in the day when they were in competition with Sears in the tool department, And there were no places in the American heartland such as Northern, Snap-On, NAPA, Enco, MSC, Grainger's, or Harbor Freight. I would guess late '60's or early '70's was when I bought an AC buzz box welder from them. I just threw this buzz box on the trash pile a last month, it still worked, but the case was about rusted away, and it probably wasn't real safe, besides I finally bought a new AC/DC welder..

It came with two electrode holders. One was a single electrode holder that you could use regular rods with for welding or a single carbon rod for gouging, brazing, or spot welding. The other electrode holder held two carbon rods, one on each leg and was used for heating items. The legs were moveable, were spring loaded and the tips would come together something like tweezers when you squeezed the handle together. First you fastened the carbons into the tips and adjusted them so the tips were about an inch apart, IIRC with the angle set narrow for a long arc and shallow for a wide arc. You would strike an arc by squeezing the handle to bring the two tips together. The arc was really bright, and there was a little dark smoke, and a slight dark residue (burnt carbon?) would be left on the items heated or welded. The carbon rods it used ranged in size from about ¼" to ½" and would last several hours. Carbons were considered non-consumable electrodes but they were consumed but at a fairly slow rate.

Reply to
Diamond Jim

Hmmm -- I'd seen this in the Lincoln catalog, but whenever I've looked at any of the on-line welding supply catalogs, they don't seem to carry it.

Anybody ever made a home-made torch?

Reply to
Andrew H. Wakefield

It's not apparent from the picture but there is a thumb control that allows you to start the arc without touching your work then allows you to adjust the arc to suit your conditions as well as compenste for the slow burn off of the carbons. I tend to run mine fairly hot, my carbon life is not great. Perhaps 20 to 30 minutes on a pair of 6"x 3/8" carbons.

The L> Hmmm -- I'd seen this in the Lincoln catalog, but whenever I've looked at

Reply to
RoyJ

Just happened to run across this site:

formatting link
They have a few carbon-arc torches, carbon electrodes with and without copper coating, etc. FYI, I've never ordered anything from them so I can't vouch for them. Maybe someone else here can.

Bert

RoyJ wrote:

Reply to
Bert

Reply to
RoyJ

Bert, these are AIR-carbon torches, very different animal. These are for scarfing, not at all what the OP seeks. - GWE

Bert wrote:

Reply to
Grant Erwin

Yep -- this just illustrates what I have found to be true. You can get the gouging torches, but the carbon-arc torches must be a special order.

I've had one or two offers to sell one used, and I may take someone up on it. On the other hand, Roy just answered one of my questions -- I wondered if the electrodes were the same for gouging or for the torch. Maybe I'll just get some electrodes and see if I can rig something up. Even if it's just a q&d kludge for now, that will give me a chance to see how much $$ I want to put into this ...

Thanks to all for the help and info!

Andy

Reply to
Andrew H. Wakefield

Head to your local welding supplier and pick up some 3/16 or 1/4 inch gouging rods, they work great for carbon arc welding.

Actually had to try this process during my weld tech program. You can aslo use a hydrogen shielding gas " Atomic Hydrogen Welding"

You will have to find a copy of the AWS hand book, Volumne 3, prior to version Seven. Three or Four would be best for in depth explanations of both processes.

John

Reply to
shop

I forgot one important point; remove the copper coating for best results.

John

Reply to
shop

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.