Personal experience with M2 is all I have on this subject.
I find that HSS tends not to tarnish. :/
So it doesn't tend to look cool like low-alloy high-carbon steel.
If allowed to, it'll go directly to red rust spots and pits tho.
HSS knives made for and used in meat cutting don't tarnish or rust
In the case of a hatchet smear it down with Vaseline? ;)
In the case of a knife smear it down with Lard. ;)
What do you think? :)
Alvin in AZ
That isn't a bad idea just not suited for what my axe will be doing. I
need something that can handle hard usage. Chopping branches, splitting
wood and the like, something that will take an edge and will hold it
even under extreme conditions. That is why I am evaluating HSS and
other tool steels, they outperform every other steel except in
corrosion resistance. That of course is why I posted here, cannot find
any info about M4's corrosion properties. I worked at a groccery store
in the meat dept when I was younger and we had to sharpen the blades
constantly, and meat is a lot softer than wood, still a thought though.
Thanks for the help and if you run into anything let me know!
Certain high speed steels are stronger than most?/all? stainless
steels and those like M2 and M4 can sure enough handle axe duty.
The main problem I have with knowing how they -all- compare is the
lack of information and interest by industry in stainless steel's
real properties. There's better stuff to be had in any and every
direction other than corrosion resistance, so why bother with the
cost of printing it out just for this dumb hick? :/ Stainlesss
steel don't even make it to the -bottom- of the lists in other
catagories BTW. :/
Thinking double bit axe or a single bit axe (that never gets driven
with a sledge hammer like a wedge;). But even an HSS wedge would
work (if heat treated right) could handle wedge duty too but put a
big handle-hole in it and that's another problem. ;) But really
tho, even the good-old ones couldn't handle much of that abuse
The main problems I see with an HSS axe is steel aquistion and then
heat treating. Not strength. :)
Easier and cheaper (ebay for odd sized left over hunks plus the
costs of heat treating) and prob'ly just as good of an axe too,
would be S7, H11, H13 or A2 etc.
Are you the guy that was on rec.knives asking about HSS and later
made some meat cutting knives from HSS ...like a year or two ago?
Alvin in AZ
ps- T1, T2, M1, M2, M3, M3(high carbon), M4, M7, M8, M10 are all
rated at the same high strength and the same high working
hardness of 63-66hrc. :) A P/M version of any of those would
be a step better in every direction except the new material
Sorry no, never made any meat cutting knives or posted about such. Also
the axe will not be used as a wedge. I am designing it as a survival
axe with durability and ruggedness as it's chief strengths. Probable
dimensions are 2 1/2'' square and 3/8'' thick with a slight angle on
the edge where the top comes to a gradual point. The handle will be
welded to the head so there will be no handle "hole" like with a wooden
handled axe. The handle will have threads on the end for an extra
extension to make it longer and allow greater force. I am taking blades
that were previously used for tree trimming (9'' L x 4'' W x 3/8''
thick) and cutting it to relative dimensions with an integral handle as
a prototype. The blades are not M4 (I really have no idea what they are
but they are very tough). I spent the better part of today chopping
hardwoods and after six hours I was still able to shave with it. The
blades have no markings on them so I am unable to determine the alloy
which is frustrating. Not only do they hold and edge extremely well but
I forgot one of 12 outside the other day, after two days of exposure to
rain and sun there is no sign of rust. Coincidentally if anyone can
help me identify what these may be made of I would be very appreciative.
I sez, forget the high speed steel for this project. :/
Make the sucker from one solid hunk of S7 or H11/H13! :)
(that's what they make jack-hammer bits from:)
If "edge holding" was added to that list then-> A2. :)
Save the uses for M2/M4 for skinning and meat cutting chores? :)
Sounds like it could be D2 or something like it?
Spark testing is free, other than the short learning curve time,
and maybe a few known samples to compare to.
After that you could tell us what the heck it is. ;)
No kidding on that.
Alvin in AZ
On Wed, 20 Apr 2005 19:02:54 +0000 (UTC) snipped-for-privacy@XX.com wrote:
Dunno, Alvin... Tradition blacksmith technique for axe making is to make
the edge from your good steel and the eye from something tough, low
carbon steel or even just iron.
I've seen it done and they start with a strip of hard steel maybe 6-8"
long, 1-1-1/2" wide and 1/2" thick for the edge an a strap maybe 6-7"
wide, 1/2" thick and maybe 12" long. first they forge the strap into
a kind of pinched U shape (pardon my ugly ASCII graphics) and then forge
weld the edge strip into the mouth of it. BTW - They usually forge the
arc for the edge into the hard steel before that.
However we've usually got real blacksmiths around here, so I'm sure one
of them can correct me on the details. There are actually several
variations on this theme. It may even be where the Japanese sword
makers first got the idea for the hard edge, soft spine that they now do
via differential heat treating. Chas should know more about that...
But I think he's making something that resembles a Buck(?) hatchet
in design. Might as well make it out of one hunk of plate-steel
like they do?
Either way :) what I'm picturing (don't know who made it but saw
a picture of it once;) is basically a hachet-shaped cleaver. :)
Alvin in AZ
Yes but those are forged and look cool! :) The one I'm picturing
(and I think this guy is too?) is one that still has the original
flat surfaces and looks more like a re-designed modern cleaver.
"S7 from ebay" ;)
Alvin in AZ
Not trying to not sound pissy...
HSS doesn't rust as easy as mild steel but no where near as rust
resistant as D2.
Make it from D2 if corrosion resistance is important.
You could prob'ly get your hands on a saw-mill planer blade that's
the right size and thickness, already heat treated and will hold an
edge as good as anything you'll be able to tell a difference in.
I have a couple out in the scrap pile right now, BTW (and I live in
the friggin desert;).
While on vacation in south central Arkansas we didn't have a hand
grinder with a cut-off blade but we did have a torch and cut off a
hunk of one (of a whole pile of these planer blades) for use as a
well drilling bit. What a mess. But the home made drill bit got
the job done and my ex-in-law's (she left me and the kids yippee;)
neighbors got water after a couple days of relatively hard work.
My son took over the torch work and found out D2 don't cut so good
with a friggin torch! :) What a waste of gas. :/
A quick run-out and measuring... 3/8"x 2+1/2"x 18" with one edge
beveled a little more acute than 45 degrees. A pain to handle
because of the weight plus that sharp-ass edge. ;)
I bet they make bigger ones than that.
But more, a guy could prob'ly get a new one if he had cash. ;)
Alvin in AZ
Good hatchets too.
Aficionados said that the steel shank gave too much vibration, others didn't
like the hard varnish on the stacked leather grip-
good hatchet, had one for years and beat the shit out of it.
I like their sample pick and rock hammer too.
That stinkin finish is harder than anything I ever saw but those yellow
stocked chinese AKKlones. Make your hands blister in a heartbeat, doing any
actual work with them.
I use tree wax for the finish- kinda like Randall knives.
"Certain high speed steels are stronger than most?/all? " From your
generalities, I will assume that you are using a very broad definition that
would include corrosion resistant steels. HP 9-4-.30 should get you to about
260ksi or more with better toughness than the tool steels. Too brittle for
me though. I like Aermet 100 which will get you to at least 300ksi,
comparable to M4 but at 5-6 times the toughness. It is not a true stainless
but is much more corrosion resistant than any tool steel. Only problem $$$$.
Aermet 100 is used for Navy Aircraft landing gear.
My father worked for a dollar day as a lumber jack for a tiny saw mill back
in the early 50's. He used a double bited ax that he only sharpened on one
side leaving the other for rough cutting when the blade might get nicked up.
If my memory is right his answer to a dull ax was a bastard file. Several
years of hard use and sharpening didn't wear the ax out. I'm sorry but
cutting tools get dull.
Polytechforum.com is a website by engineers for engineers. It is not affiliated with any of manufacturers or vendors discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.