More on "The Case for Working With Your Hands"

Thanks Ed - I think the reviewers analysis is correct - and I was wondering how you could get from a self contained essay to a book. Its not the "real" world - more some Rousseau fantasy of choosing what you do, when you do it, and for people who are willing to pay you well for it. Wonder if he has a wife/kids/mortgage to support? - that narrows your choices considerably. Crawford is all for the "craft" industries, romanticizes them well (not sure, but did he say he could just walk out, go fishing whenever he likes) possibly like a lot of people here, where you can pick and choose your projects - he doesn't HAVE to produce an endless series of small widgets each and every day. So saying that, it was a nice read, echoes of a nicer world...

AAndrew VK3BFA.

I'm going to wait until I read it, but the review does imply that the question I had -- whether one can sustain a book-length feature about this subject without romanticizing it -- may be answered in the negative. Nevertheless, is sounds like it's damned good for as long as it keeps its head of steam.

BTW, he is married. I don't know if he has kids.

-- Ed Huntress

I do believe that at some point the current trade imbalance between he "west" and the developing countries is going to equalize. When that happens there'll be (relatively) more money in 'craft' work everywhere in the world, and manufactured goods won't be dirt cheap any more; if at that point we can't pick up and start doing 'real' work we're going to be a country of managers with no one willing to work for us.

While in Africa I bought a South African copy of Popular Mechanics. It had an article about "The Dangerous Book For Boys" and its phenomenal success. It seems that recent generations of boys have been repressed and feminized and so men now lack the skills boys used to have and are averse to risk, having been overprotected and mollycoddled, even though they need risk to feel complete as men. Here's an article about the book:

This is something similar that I had when I was a kid.

David

Yep 9 years of college to get an engineering degree with post grad studies so I wouldn't have to get dirt under my finger nails. Some how I forgot to break the habit though, and just spent the week with manuel labor, tearing down a 30X40 metal hangar. Geesh! Where did I go wrong?

Have you got food, shelter, place to live, happy?

The most important question being the last, happiness. If you have that it doesn't get any better ;-)

Manuel labor? You had a Mexican helping you?

I thought he was from Barcelona!.

No, no one of Mexican descent, but as a matter of fact one of the partners in the hangar had Puerto Rican ancestry though. Does that count?

Stu

Matthew Crawford was on the second part of the Diane Rehm Show today (Tue, 06-02-2009). The audio wasn't available yet when I just looked, should be able to get it here before long though:

It should turn up here too as a Podcast (mp3 format):

If it works for you, its fine with me! ;)

I just wish the Mexican that owns the lot next door would come cut up the tree that fell across my fence form his side, before I have to call the county on him.

That would be quite a swim, wouldn't it? ;-)