Update:
Took spark plug out. The piston is not moving. WIth the tiller in gear, pulling the recoil starter, the tiller will move. (Meaning I guess the crank is not snapped in half or soemthing.
I plan on taking the engine out tonight.
By the way, I have a 3.5 horse engine layign around. It was attached ot a pump at one time. Think this would work? It would probably be underpowered.
Could I weld the current rod?