ARM: Review - Italeri 1/72 Scale KV-1 m41

Kit Review: Italeri 1/72 scale Kit No. 7049; KV-1 m41; 106 parts (104
in olive stryene, 2 steel colored vinyl track runs); price about US
$14.00
Advantages: re-release of ESCI kit No. 8037, easy assembly and good
appearance for wargaming
Disadvantages: "pantographed" version of 35 year old Tamiya kit
Rating: Recommended
Recommendation: for small scale modelers, especially wargamers
Modelers are a quirky lot; many are able to split hairs on exactly
when a specific sub-variant of a German tank was built and where it
was used, or what options were found on a sub-variant of M4 Sherman,
but most still have few clues about how the Soviet tanks were built or
what designations Russian historians have given them for convenience's
sake.
First off, this new kit from Italeri is a KV-1 Model 1942 with
"heavy" cast turret from UZTM and a late production hull from Factory
No. 200 - essentially modeled on the two tanks provided by the Soviets
in late 1942 to the US (S/N 11502) and Britain (S/N 11306) for study.
This is the same exact one used by Tamiya in 1972 to produce its kit,
which is pretty much what ESCI did about five years later to produce
their own line of 1/72 kits. Italeri, who now owns the old ESCI molds,
has re-released it in a new box and with far better decals than ESCI
ever seemed to provide. (At least Italeri did not call it a "KV-IC" or
the German designation!)
As such, it follows the same parts breakdown as the Tamiya one other
than a multi-piece hull instead of a "motorization" tub like Tamiya
used. It is a reasonably sharply molded kit with very nice detailing
of the small parts, and also comes with two figures (copies of the
Tamiya crew figures in their kit) but with the same proportions (the
figures are 23mm high, which works out to 5'5" tall - Soviet tankers
were later short, but not in this tank!)
Since it was a "mini-me" of the Tamiya kit, it comes with two 95
liter fuel tanks and two ZIP bins for the fenders, the same
incorrectly located driver-mechanic's hatch (too far to the rear) and
all of the other failings of that kit. Sadly they also duplicated the
"first generation" vinyl tracks with no interior face details - silky
smooth.
For wargamers, however, this kit should be welcome as it is a very
easy assembly and looks a lot better than most of the other kits
produced in the past such as the Fujimi 1/76 scale ones. If no
detailing is desired, a good modeler should be able to slap this puppy
together in about an hour or two.
Markings and finishing are included for three tanks: "Moskovkiy
OSOAviakhimovets" in white with red lettering; "Shchors" in 4BO green
with white lettering; and a mottled whitewash over green tank with the
name "KIM" on it in black. (Oddly the color swatch for "flat white" is
flat black; Italeri should pay closer attention to its box art as this
is the second one with mislabeled colors on it.)
Overall anyone hoping for a new Italeri ground-up KV-1 kit will be
disappointed, but it should be quite popular with 25mm wargamers (it
bears a logo saying "ALZO ZERO Wargames Approved" to prove that
point!)
Thanks to Bob Lewen from MRC for the review sample.
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne
Loading thread data ...
Other than having my name on it, does this kit have any advantages over the Trumpeter model?
(kim)
Reply to
kim
I haven't seen their 1/72 kit so can't comment, but would bet it has fewer parts and easier to assemble but lesser details. The 1/35 scale Trumpeter kits are among the best going.
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne
Er, the Italeri one has fewer parts etc. My mistake!
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne
on 7/13/2007 5:56 PM snipped-for-privacy@aol.com said the following:
"I haven't seen their 1/72 kit so can't comment, but would bet */_it_/* has fewer parts and easier to assemble but lesser details".
You started to write italeri ( *
it* ), you just didn't finish it. :-)
Reply to
willshak
Nice cover - you could have a career in politics! 8-)
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne
I'm not that picky it's just that my local hobby store just took delivery of four different types of Trumpeter KV-1 of which one is the heavy turret type.
From a wargaming perspective I prefer the approach adopted by Airfix on the T-34 and M3 of having interchangeable turrets on a single hull.
(kim)
Reply to
kim
Right, never understood the aversion to that as the diehards will still have to buy TWO kits to make two different models. And with the "mix and match" sprues in use by nearly everybody today it wouldn't cost them much more at that.
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.