| I would bet that these problems actually hardly ever occur. Why? | Because | (a) Linemen will treat any line as energized, except when they have | grounded and/or disconnected it themselves and can verify that it | is and will remain safe.
If the service drop to a single home has come loose from the pole, the lineman MAY ... when working for 24 hours straight during a major emergency situation ... get sloppy and fail to properly test for voltage on the wires coming from the house.
Mentally, they know their own lines have lethal voltages. But after working with hundreds or thousands of homes, none of which have any voltage on them, they could just fail to test that next one with the generator running. That failure might be because having done so many so fast, they thought they did check this one.
And there is the chance the situation changes while working on it.
| (b) If you try to backfeed the grid (which means backfeeding a lot of | electricity users at once), the breaker on the generator will | simply pop due to overload, so the situation dangerous to a | lineman will correct itself very quickly.
This is only if the line *is* connected to the grid. If the line to the house is down, there is no such backfeed taking place. It MIGHT be sizzling on the ground ... or not.
| (c) If a generator is connected to a de-energized utility line, and | then the utility line comes back on, the breaker on the generator | will simply pop long before the generator is damaged (after all, | that's what the generator is there for).
You assume it is connected. When major storm damage takes place, the lines can be done right there. I've seen home service drops down just due to small thunderstorms. Imagine what 4 hurricanes in a few weeks can do.
| By the way, I am in no way advocating that people connect their | generators in an unsafe, non-approved or illegal fashion. Even if | these problems occur extremely rarely, you really don't want it to | happen to you. But I'm getting quite tired of the constant repetition | of mantras such as "if you use a stinger cord, you will kill linemen | and blow up your house", which I think is just paranoia and | fearmongering.
Certainly the "will" part of it is overblow. It could be worded better. But it is important to realize that you could be energizing a downed line and not know it because there is no load there. You _could_ kill a lineman, or someone else that happens across your wires and does not understand that power can be coming the other way.
| Again, I'm not asking for opinions whether connecting generators the | wrong way is a good or bad idea (I know it is a bad idea). I am | asking for verification that it actually causes harm and continues to | do so.
I do not personally know of a case where it has. But I don't work for an electric company, nor do I know any linemen. I have listened in on the radio traffic following a big ice storm that took out thousands of poles and nearly all the service to the county. While I was lucky and had my power back on in 2 days, some parts of the county waited 2 weeks. Some areas lost _every_ pole as far as you could see (which was quite far given the flat terrain). In that radio traffic, supervisors were very regularly warning the linemen of various safety procedures. They may very well have been tired of hearing it, but they would also be tired from the work, and could get sloppy. I think that was the right thing for the supervisors to do.
Although I don't know of cases, I do know it is very plausible to happen. If someone does connect a generator wrong and a lineman is killed, then I would hope to see them charged with 2nd degree manslaughter.