I was never very good at the heat transfer thing.......picking / estimating /
guess heat transfer coefficients was too much black art for me.
I've got ~30 to 40' of unisulated 3/4" (trade size) copper tube running through
an unheated (but insulated) crawlspace.
Here's my question
Is it worth the savings to drag my 50 year old body through the access hole &
put on some of the split tube foam insulation? Or is the savings high enough
to justify paying to have it done?
Hot water temp ~120F but sometimes as high as 140F (temp boosted to compensate
for very high shower usage)
Crawlspace tmep ~45F
Flow rate ~1gpm
Daily hot water usage ~50 to 150 gallons
How many Btu's, per gallonn of water used, are being lost through the copper
On 25 Dec 2004 00:52:12 GMT, email@example.com (Bob K 207) wrote:
I am going to pick numbers out of the air, just to get some kind of
feel for the numbers involved.
I suppose that:
after last use of the day, the water will cool to ambient with or
without a jacket.
after first use of the day, the delay til next use will determine the
cooling of the pipe contents which will vary with the thermal
impedance of the pipe. (1)
during use, the terminal temperature will be lower with uninsulated
pipe than using sleeve. (2)
(1) uninsulated Time constant = 6 minutes insulated tc = 18 min
(TC = time to fall to 37% of initial delta t )
(2) T input 140 f output 114F uninsulated, 134 F insulated.
Suppose interval between a shower end and next shower begin is 10
Suppose power is 10cents per kWhr.
Volume at risk: 40 ft X 12 in/ft X pi X 3/4 in / 4 = 283 cu in 4633 cc
Volume per day 120 gal
delta t = 140 - 45 = 95F
Uninsulated Energy loss (1)
=====================Temperature drop in 10 minutes no flow 95 X 0.63 = 60 F
plus 35 X 2/3 X 0.63 = 15F - this gives 140 - 60 - 15 = 65F = 36C
Heat loss 36 C X 4633 cc X 4.2 joule/cal = 0.7 MJ
Number of showers at 15 min /shower = 120/15 = 8
Total standing loss uninsulated 7 X 0.7 MJ = 4.9 MJ per day
10 cents kWhr = 10 cents per 3.6 MJ
Cost/day of standing loss = 4.9/3.6 X 10 cents = 14 cents /day
= $49.70 per year. Amortize over 10 years total cost $497
Insulated Energy Loss (1)
===================Temp drop in 10 min no flow 95 X 0.63 X 10/18 = 38 F = 21C
Heat loss 21C X 4633 cc X 4.2 joule/cal = 0.4 MJ
Total standing loss insulated 7 X 0.4 MJ = 2.8 MJ per day
Cost/day of standing loss = 2.8/3.6 X 10 cents = 8 cents /day
= $28.39 per year
Over 10 years, total standing heat loss cost $284
Uninsulated Energy Loss (2)
=====================140 - 114F = 26F delta T X 120 gal/day
= 14.5C X 120 gal/day X 8 lb/gal / 2.2 lb/kg
X 1000 cc/kg X 4.2 joule/cal = 26.6MJ/day
Cost per day of running water heat loss 26.6 / 3.6 X 10 cents
= 74 cents/day = $270 /yr
Over 10 years total running heat loss cost = $2700
Insulated Energy Lass (2)
===================140 - 134 = 6F delta T X 120 gal/day
= 3.3C X 120 gal/day X 8 lb/gal /2.2 lb/kg
X 1000 cc/kg X 4.2 J/cal = 6.1 MJ/day
Cost per day of running water heat loss 6.1 / 3.6 X 10 cents
= 17 cents/day = $61.94 /yr
Over 10 years total running water heat loss cost = $619
Compare cost of heat losses - 10 years
==============================uninsulated: 497 + 2700 = $3197
insulated: 284 + 619 = $903
Cost of insulation ? say $2 per yard
40/3 X $2 = $28
Cost of labor to apply:
2 hours at $50/hr = $100
Present cost of application $128
Future cost of application at 10 years
128 X (1.10)^10 = $332
using 10% pa opportunity cost.
==========These numbers lead to an estimated
saving of $2294 - $332 = $1962 in ten years time.
or a payback period less than two years.
But your mileage may vary.
This sounds like an example of proper selection of the thermodynamic universe -
you said it was insulated -
if the pipes are between the insulation and the floor, the heat lost from the
pipe goes up into the living space.
It is not lost to the dwelling. However, it may add to cooling load.
if it is insulated between the pipes and the floor - as in the joists - the
heat is lost.
As to non-heat considerations - If the ambient can go near freezing because
of venting, etc., or the copper is over bare damp acidic soil, or if you use
the plumbing as a service ground and you don't have a secure fitting ground
rod, you will need frost and galvanic protection.
Polytechforum.com is a website by engineers for engineers. It is not affiliated with any of manufacturers or vendors discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.