Why do they hammer foundation piles in instead of screwing them down?

Nov 08, 2026 Last reply: 1 week ago 3 Replies

Most relevant reply

walt.morrison

For me the answer to why big jobs still hammer came from a small job, funny enough. Had a helical crew do footings for a backyard studio a few summers back and it was genuinely quiet, one little excavator with a drive head spinning them in. The catch showed up on the third pile…

Read the full reply

There's a crew putting in an addition on the house down the street from me and for the past few days it's just been this machine banging long supports into the ground over and over. Whole block shakes. It got me wondering why they don't just make them like giant screws and twist them into the soil instead. Seems like it would be quieter and way less banging around.



I did a bit of reading and aparently screw piles are a real thing, mostly for decks and smaller jobs, but big buildings still get driven piles. Is it a strength thing? Like a screwed-in post doesn't grip as well once you load it up with a whole structure? Or is it just that hammering is faster when you've got hundreds of them to do?



Also curious if soil type matters. Our yard is mostly clay, and I remember reading somewhere that clay can sort of squeeze around whatever you push into it. Would that make twisting harder or easier? Genuinely just trying to understand the thinking here because the noise has me wondering if there's a better way that nobody uses.


Screw piles are real, they're called helicals, and I've used them on a few jobs. Funny thing is your intuition about strength is backwards. A helical pile grips the soil really well because the big steel flights on the shaft act like a screw threading into the earth. Once the helix plate bears on undisturbed soil below frost line, it can carry a serious load. We've hung whole additions on them. So it's not a grip problem.

I'd push back on the threading part of that explanation. The flights don't hold the pile like a screw holds in wood. Almost all the capacity comes from the helix plates bearing down on the soil underneath them, like little footings stacked on a shaft. The soil above the plate doesn't really grip the steel the way threads engage. That's why installers watch torque so closely during the twist-in, since it tells you how solid the bearing is down there. So yeah, they carry real loads, but it's not for the reason you gave, and that distinction acutally matters when you're sizing them.

For me the answer to why big jobs still hammer came from a small job, funny enough. Had a helical crew do footings for a backyard studio a few summers back and it was genuinely quiet, one little excavator with a drive head spinning them in. The catch showed up on the third pile when they hit a buried slab of old concrete about four feet down. They just repositioned and kept going, but it got me thinking. On a hundred pile job with rocky or unpredictable ground you can't have the rig stalling out every afternoon, so a hammer that powers through anything wins. Clay itself is the easy case, it cuts clean. It's the random junk underground that keeps the big boys hammering.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required