I had a tooth extracted today. It had been crowned with gold. They gave me
back the gold crown, tooth still in it of course.
I seem to recall hearing that Coca-Cola actually dissolves teeth. Is that
a workable solution to removing the old tooth from the gold crown? Is
there a better one?
"Grant Erwin" wrote: (clip) I seem to recall hearing that Coca-Cola
actually dissolves teeth. Is that
It must be pretty slow--else most of the population would be toothless. I
suggest tap-tap-tap with a small hammer. Or leave the tooth in, and have a
jeweler add a small ring, so you can wear it on a chain around your neck.
"Grant Erwin" wrote
in message news:1e4mk.309$xv.240@trnddc02...
Try a stronger acid. The Phosphoric and Citric
acids in Coke are weak and slow.
Maybe HCL/Muriatic? Might even try a little
battery electrolyte --that's
Don't try a mix of Nitric and Sulfuric:-)
Melt it out with a propane torch. Improvise a casting crucible by grinding
and compressing bentonite clay (hidden in the grocery store disguised as
the cheapest unscented store-brand kitty litter). Or from silicate furnace
Gold dealers will give you about half the bullion value of the gold scrap.
They're in it for a profit. Likely no more than $50 or $100 cash for an
old crown, so it may not even be worth the trouble. But you could play
with the jewelry style of metalworking, say casting and finishing a finger
Dilute HCl, .1 N dissolves Hydroxyapatite. In the absence of nitrate,
this will not dissolve the gold, though it may extract alloying metals
such as copper from the surface, leaving a frosty surface.
You can speed this up in a beaker floating in an ultrasonic cleaner.
This cavitates the organic materials as well as speeding up the
dissolution of the HA.
Coke will not work because it is a very dilute solution of phosphoric
acid, which gave rise to stories about it removing rust from bumpers.
HA can be prepared from H3PO4 and CaOH2 .
On Wed, 6 Aug 2008 01:22:12 -0400, with neither quill nor qualm, "Tom
Gardner" quickly quoth:
What, and ruin the shape of the thing you're selling to be melted?
Chaos, panic, and disorder--my work here is done.
Gold crowns are not made from amalgams. Gold amalgams are used for
fillings. Silver amalgam fillings are always removed before a tooth is
The reason that an amalgam filled tooth gets a crown in the first place,
is mostly, that there is new decay around or even under the filling, so
the tooth has to be cleaned and the amalgam is removed to make place for
either an inlay, overlay or a full crown. You cannot prep a tooth
properly for a crown, with the amalgam still in place.
It not necessary to put a torch to a tooth with a crown still on it.
Since the tooth has already been extracted, it will have become brittle
rather rapidly, because it is no longer fed by blood vessels and nerves.
Just take a pair of pliers to it, and it'll break in pieces quite easily.
BTW, before I became a goldsmith, I spent three years in dental school
at the university of Amsterdam trying to become a dentist.
I put the crown, tooth in it, in a bench vise, minor closure, CRACK, all
the tooth pieces fell out. Took about 3 seconds flat.
Now I have 2.7 grams of gold crown and another couple grams of whatever alloy
they use under ceramic. Oh, the bench vise cracked off about 95% of the ceramic
too, on that one.
I don't doubt that you have described how it is supposed to be. But the
world isn't perfect, and there is no cost to being a little cautious
while heating the gold alloy. It might be contaminated if the dentist
didn't get all the amalgam out.
This is almost impossible. However, in the unlikely event, that this
was the case, the work was done by an exceptionally bad dentist.
Getting old silver amalgam fillings out, is quite easy, since the moment
they are touched with a drill, they pretty much crumble and get ripped
out. The pieces fly in all directions (inside the mouth of course),
because of the characteristics of the material once it has been in a
tooth for some time.
It is also very likely, that if in fact there was still some silver
amalgam left under the crown, the patient would have developed new decay
and with it quite a severe toothache. The crown would have failed, have
to be removed, the tooth would have to be cleaned again, and a new crown
would have to be made and placed.
Also, if he did choose to heat it, the cement with which the crown is
affixed to the tooth would decompose long before the gold would melt.
And lastly, even if there were a silver amalgam filling under the crown,
heating it would most likely be harmless. It is unlikely that he is
going to get hurt from "Mercury vapors" from a single silver amalgam
A mouthful of silver amalgam fillings is a lot more dangerous to a
person's sustained health, than heating one that is no longer in a mouth.
Before the advent of electroplating, precious metal smiths used the
extremely poisonous technique of "fire gilding" to gold plate silver
objects. This was done with gold amalgams.