What about studs which are wet from water, is there enough lubrication from water as compared to a dry stud to affect the torque reading?
- Vote on answer
- posted
18 years ago
What about studs which are wet from water, is there enough lubrication from water as compared to a dry stud to affect the torque reading?
I have somewhere here a small manual that lists the effects of various lubricants on thread torques, but I can't find it this minute. Might be at work. I don't think water was listed, as its lubricity under that much pressure should be insignificant. I'll see if I can find that book and post a few figures.
Dan
Likely that the manufacturer expected clean and dry threads. Lubricating with anti-seize assures overtorquing....
...but I suspect that you need to try a quality wrench.... Matco, Mac, Snap-on.... etc...
or better yet, break them loose by hand...
I found my little book. The effect of various lubricants on torque settings looks like this:
Steel, non-plated, dry: 1.00 of torque spec. Grease with copper, graphite, and aluminum flakes: 0.85 of spec Zinc electroplate 0.85 C5A copper-graphite anti-seize 0.80 Motor Oil SAE 20 0.80 Dri-Lock adhesive coating 0.75 Zinc anti-seize 0.75 Graphite 0.70 Grease with graphite 0.65 Moly-50 anti-seize (moly disulphide) 0.65 Dri-Lock 200 0.60 Graphite and motor oil 0.55 Oil (heavy) 0.50 Moly-Cote 0.45 Never-Seize 0.45
These are just a few from a lengthy list. Be careful with that Never-Seize; using a standard torque will more than double the stress in the fastener.
Dan
How about this one
If the 800 ft-lbs. is for real, you'll either break the lug nut loose of flip the car over.... and I'm really not sure which!
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.