Hi everyone,
Thanks for your replies.
I cannot thread the rod through the support and/or put a nut & washer on the other side of the support, or change the dimensions to larger parts. The "support" is actually a round bearing housing with a flat milled on it where the rod threads in. The threaded rod is basically a lever that oscillates the housing back and forth. Everything is in a very tight space, and the rod threads in right over a bearing, and practically bottoms out on the bearing (this is why I cannot go deeper and use a longer thread).
I figured I would just tolerance the thread length so it does not bottom out on the bearing OD. Moving the needle roller bearing out from underneath the rod does not help much since everything is cantilever mounted, and there is still a shaft underneath the rod even if the bearing is moved (you only get about a .05" addition to thread length). Also, this would put the bearings closer together, and I want to keep them spaced further apart if at all possible.
I also thought of forgetting about the thread length tolerance, and threading the rod into the housing before the bearing bore is drilled. This way, if a little thread extends into the bearing bore, it will be machined away when the bearing bore is drilled. The problem I see here is that if I have to take the rod out and put it back in, it will probably not go back in right.
Welding the joint seems undesirable (it will deform the bearing bore) . Heat would also deform the bore in the rod itself. I also don't have the space to add any type of collar as garry suggested.
Based on all of the feedback I have gotten from this and other forums, it seems the size of the lip where the rod necks down is fairly unimportant, and I should keep the OD of the threads as large as possible. It also seems a course pitch thread is better than a fine or extra fine thread, even though there may be less threads over the .183" length.
I misunderstood what tomcas suggested with the set screw, I can see it would not be an extra step, and may be a better choice than machining the shoulder since I would have threads along the full .183" length. I would probably use loc-tite to keep everything from backing out or loosening. I am not 100% sure it would really be stronger "overall" though, becasue then the weak point looks like it would be the thin wall left on the rod after it is bored through and tapped for the set screw.
The way things are now, the existing 6mm OD hole in the center of the rod does not go all the way through, and the drill point stops about .12" from the shoulder where the threaded portion of the rod necks down. Drilling the hole all the way through and using a set screw looks like it could weaken things overall, (i.e., the threads are stronger, but the weak point then becomes the thin wall of the rod where it connects to the housing ) I don't know that for sure though. If a 1/4" OD set screw is used, I would have a 1/6" wall remaining on the rod where it connects to the housing, but it does not seem like much.
How close could I realistically get the threads to the shoulder where the rod necks down? I guessed that with a 5/16-24 thread, I would loose one thread at the shoulder and wind up having three useful threads.
If I have the space, I guess the best solution may be to do away with the necked down portion, and try to thread the OD of some 3/8" drill rod. The rod threads into a 1" OD round, but it is right at the edge, i.e., the center of the 3/8" OD rod is only .236" from the edge or end of the housing.
When I said before that the load tends to pry the rod out of the support, I did not mean that the load actually caused the joint to fail, but just that that is how the load acts on the system.
As I understand it, you can have cumulative stress on threads in a cyclic application, so you can test it, it can work fine, but fail down the road. I have no way to simulate a few years of use in a short time, and that's why I made the post on the board to get feedback. The loads should be fairly moderate, say 10 to 15 pounds but the thread is so short I wanted to get some feedback so I can try to do the best thing right from the start. Even though the loads are moderate, the short thread length just worries me.
Thanks again for your help. John