Is there a standard catalog of rectangular cross-section O-rings? It's a hot-water application, in fact the group gasket for an old espresso machine.
The dimensions need to be about 2 1/4" OD, 1 7/8" ID but a little over 1/4" thick, say 5/16". The thickness is the sticking point. Long ago I machined a teflon ring for the job, but to my supreme regret I damaged it on removal and the only remaining stock on hand is .250" thick. That's not quite enough.
McMaster sells 3/8" sheets, but the smallest piece is six by six inches, $60 and lots of work. To my surprise there's nothing on Amazon. Tap does not list teflon at all. Back in the day I just went to Abe Schuster Plastics in Oakland CA and bought a bit of scrap 8-)
It's possible a round-section Buna O-ring could be crammed into the groove but it looks like Parker does not make one that comes close (too skinny) and the curved cross section will promote un-centering of the gland.
Another option is to use the too-thin teflon and put a slim backing o-ring under it, Parker 2-034 or 2-137.
Writing this helped collect my thoughts, if you have anything to add please do.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska