Ig, the other day, I replace the front and rear way covers on my r2e4, because they were cracked.
I selected 1/16" neoprene, medium soft, and the rear one snagged under the lead screw covers -- and tore.
I can't see any significant difference between my cover and the one that came off, except perhaps that the old one is a tiny bit (0.010") thicker, and just a little stiffer.
Your base casting is almost identical to mine. Did you use the flexible skirts on yours (or not change them), or did you install bellows covers?
LLoyd