ARM: Review - Osprey Modeling - US Tank Destroyers

Book Review: Osprey Modelling No. 13: Modelling US Army Tank Destroyers of WWII
by Steven J. Zaloga, consulting editor Robert Oehler; Osprey Publishing,
Botley, Oxfordshire, England, 2004; 80 pp. with color photos and illustrations;
price about US $18.95; ISBN 1-84176-799-9
Advantages: Very clear text and good photo coverage provide a wealth of details
and information of interest to any armor modeler; provides good information on
specific subject kits
Disadvantages: Like all modelers' guides, fixed at a point in time to the kits
then available
Rating: Highly Recommended
Recommendation: To all armor modelers, and all modelers in general
Guide books to modeling are a problem of sorts, as they have to stake out a
section of turf and then define it. The bugaboo is that just as you have
described one series or class of kits, new ones come out that supplant or
replace the current entries, thus limiting the value of the book as a whole.

Happily, with the continuing line of good works from well-known armor modeler
Steve Zaloga, this is rarely a problem, as about 95% of the techniques he
shares and discusses are of use to any armor model, and many of them are even
"cross-discipline" and pertain to other modeling genres as well (aircraft,
ships, cars, figures, sci-fi, and especially model railroading).
This book focuses on WWII US tank destroyers, a colorful and interesting class
of ultimately flawed vehicles and guns. When tanks came about in WWI, nobody
thought much about them as reliability was so low. But in the 1930s, when tanks
began to emerge as a new threat on the battlefield, there was a bit of
reactionary aversion to them by the "traditional"
combat arms: infantry, artillery, cavalry. In the US Army, as a result there
was a rise of the tank destroyer, either a gun or lightly armed, highly mobile
vehicle that could kill tanks before they could cause great destruction. Based
on forced modeling ? and a heavy dose of branch biases by the aforementioned
three branches ? tank destroyers were "demonstrably superior" to tanks during
the 1941 Louisiana Maneuvers. As such, they were adopted for the US Army and
battalions were created in short order.
The reality was that what the Army wound up with was either weak or
ineffective towed weapons or tank-like vehicles that could not really battle
other tanks. After high losses and much sacrifice during the war, the tank
destroyer concept was quietly dropped after the war was over.
From a modeling standpoint, however, it created some neat-looking vehicles
that are fun to model, as they have open tops and busy interiors. Steve turns
his attention in this book to four basic subjects: a 1/35 scale M36 90mm GMC in
a winter camouflage, based on the new Academy kit; a 1/72 Extratech kit of the
M10 3" GMC; a 1/35 scale model of the M18 Hellcat based on the AFV Club kit;
and a 1/35 conversion of the same AFV Club M18 into the M39 Armored Utility
Vehicle for towing the M5 3" Antitank gun. But in passing, Steve also comments
on most of the available kits of tank destroyers, and provides inside into the
Dodge-based M6 37mm GMC, the halftrack mounted M3 75mm GMC, and the M36B1 90mm
GMC on the M4A3 chassis.
Unlike some of the other Osprey authors ? or many other modeling authors in
general ? Steve is able to show clear, concise photos and text of what he
does and how he does it. He explains his techniques, shows how it is done (and
the interim steps of what the effect or part looks like in transition) and also
the finished result. Too many "authors" seem more intent on bragging about
their achievements and showing only a finished effort, usually badly. The
editors of such publications should use books like this one as their reference
standard of "how to do it" to ensure a better product.
While Steve is a consultant to several manufacturers ? providing advice,
plans and references where needed ? he has no affiliation with any
manufacturer on a paid basis, and thus bad kits or kits with errors are called
out and highlighted. This includes comparisons of the three available M10 3"
GMC kits ? Academy, AFV Club, and Tamiya ? and demonstrably shows which one
is most accurate (and ergo the best one to begin a modeling project.)
Overall this is an excellent book for the money, and even if you do not build
armor, you can find many, many useful tips and hints within its covers.
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
Loading thread data ...

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.