3D spiral

Is there a way of extruding a circle or any shape along a 3D spiral.
Such as a coil spring or a handrail for a spiral staircase.
I have tried solids and surfaces but nothing works.
Any help would be appreciated.
Thanks
Richardb
Reply to
Richard Busuttil
Loading thread data ...
Is it possible to extrude a circle or any shape along a 3d spiral as for a coil spring or a handrail for a spiral staircase.
I have tried solids and surfaces but nothing works.
Any help would be appreciated.
Thanks Richardb
Reply to
Richard B
HiHo; Use "Rhino" from
formatting link

Reply to
bestafor
Thanks for your help. I may try to get Rhino but does this mean that AutoCAD cannot handle spirals?
Regards Richardb
Reply to
Richard B
Try this spiral lisp routine:
formatting link
Conny
"Richard B" skrev i meddelandet news:3f89652c$0$30614$ snipped-for-privacy@news.optusnet.com.au...
Reply to
Conny Klasson
Hi
"Richard B" skrev i en meddelelse news:3f89652c$0$30614$ snipped-for-privacy@news.optusnet.com.au...
Ofcaurse AutoCAD do Spirals, you just need an application or, just one spiral that you then make into a block , and then insert in different scale, that way you can make many different spirals from one. But a Lisp application will do the first spiral you need , and such app can be found with a search. Realy, I would try a poverfull search engine and try search for "spiral.lsp" ;)) P.C.
Reply to
P.C.
Yes, get a different cad program. Turbocad will do that with great ease.
Reply to
CW
Yes. That is only one of many things it can't handle.
Reply to
CW
No, you can make railings without twisting the profiles. I wrote a LISP to do that. In case of interest ask me. regards Jochen
formatting link

"Richard B" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:3f89652c$0$30614$ snipped-for-privacy@news.optusnet.com.au...
Reply to
jochen
I have a few drawings done just send me the coordiantes needed i will be able to come up with a dwg in cad 14 extension file
Regards
Rob
Reply to
Robert
Rich, There is a way to do this in cad. Now, i havn't done this in a while, but i can give you the basic concept. (for what its worth)
Fist off, create a circle at the desired radius/dia, use the trim command to cut the circle in half. now you need to rotate the ucs so that the Y axis is in the direction of the former Z direction. Figure out the slope or angle in which the spiral will accending. now rotate the half-circle so that it is angled upward at the desired slope. now copy, and rotate the half-circle 180d (using the original ucs) use osnaps to connect the two halves. (so that they form a spiral) once you have gotten the spiral at the approprite height and angle, you need to change the ucs once again so that one of the endpoints (top or bottom) is perpendicular with the ucs. after that all you need to do is join all the line segments to creat one line. Create the shape that the actual handrail "grip" looks like, and make it into a region. Once it's a region, it's just a matter of extruding the shape along a path, which would be the spiral.
I hope this helped a little more than telling you to buy new software. Good luck!!!
Daniel Sandy
Reply to
Dan S.
Say, why not to use a "Torus" tool from Solids toolbar to do that? Or draw a cross section of the desired handrail/spring and use Revolve
Reply to
Igor Mironenko
This would give a helix not a spiral. (Constant diameter in Z direction.)
Reply to
Michael Bulatovich
Wait.......that's what he asked for: a helix. But isn't there another problem with this approach? Don't you end up with an ellipse in plan?
Reply to
Michael Bulatovich
Dear Jochen,
Thanks for your reply.
You wrote,
Yes I am interested. I would like to learn how to extrude any shape especially a rectangle/square, channel, UB beam etc along a 3D spiral/coil/helix without twisting. Circles are not a problem now.
I have tried a few other suggestions by others but I did not explaine my problem well enough as their suggestions might be OK for simple presentation drawings.
Looking forward to your reply Thanks again Richardb
Reply to
Richard B
"Richard B" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:3f895268$0$15134$ snipped-for-privacy@news.optusnet.com.au...
Reply to
jochen
Hi Richard,
thank you for your interest in my ideas.
some times ago I started to develop programs to make SOLIDs from surface-models, i.e. to get a general solution for the "unexplode"-command for SOLIDs. And now I've found a first solution for SOLIDs bounded by plane faces (REGIONs). But for your problem about untwisted profiles it is quite enough to use my RS2S.lsp. Using it you can create the SOLID laying between 2 RULESURF-surfaces having equal SURFTAB1-values. I take the first 4-point- surface( it must not be a plane one) and the corresponding 4-point-face from the second RULESURF-surface and create the HEXAEDER laying between them. It consists of TETRAEDERs and PENTAEDERs. Finally I unite these single SOLIDs and the results you can see from the appended examples- see especially the GELAENDER1.DWG (i.e. railing). The accuracy is depending on the value of the SURFTAB1, i.e. it is up to 256. Beeing correct I have to say that you really cannot create twisted surfaces in AutoCAD as I know - depending on the ACIS-kernel but the results got by triangulation seem to be sufficient. Other Informations you will see from my
formatting link
( unfolding , PEDIT3D). Regards from good (c)old Germany Jochen PS. The attachment was not transferred please contact me via snipped-for-privacy@t-online.de
"Richard B" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:3f895268$0$15134$ snipped-for-privacy@news.optusnet.com.au...
Reply to
jochen

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.