First off, let me say that I am no expert in this subject, but I would like to hear the latest current thinking of the professional electrical community as to what the current thinking is on this and if any 20007 NEC code changes can be expected as a result.
Detailed background information on each case is available at the following links:
Argument in favor of multi-point primary neutral grounding:
- is favored by most utilities
- has less expensive capital costs (fewer conductors - insulators - uses single bushing transformers vs. double bushing, etc.)
- Perceived as safer to lineman (assured neutral grounding at multiple points)
- Easier on transformers (less intense surges and easier to connect lightning arrestors to).
- Works better for isolated distant distribution transformers (as typically found on US farms)
On the downside...the multi-point neutral primary grounding system...
- Can produce undesirable stray voltages (more properly - stray currents) under the right set of circumstances. Stray currents may be harmful to livestock and humans.
- Can cause shocks in swimming pools and electric showers.
What is the current thinking on this subject? I understand that Europe bans the multi-point neutral grounded systems, but Europe has fewer isolated transformers serving distant farmhouses.
Beachcomber
- Can lead to shocks in swiming pools and electric showers