I've stayed out of the political free-for-alls because I come here to learn about metalworking - not to save the world.
But Al struck a nerve that has been jangling for a while.
First, as an American citizen, (FWIW) my appologies to your family and most especially your father, Mr. Moore. Our history, right or wrong, but our history, none the less.
Times _have_ changed.
Can you imagine McCarthy dealing with the Internet?
Or allowing me to express my own foolish opinions?
Not likely. (as you all well know)
Anyway, here's the problem as best I see it...
I'm having a hard time with this election.
Maybe like Gunner and the rest, if I could find some detail to get angry about, I could make up my mind easily.
But I'm still choking the big picture.
Democratic Socialism or Republican Fascism?
What kind of country are we.
What kind of country are we becoming?
Richard
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
G
Gunner
Pretty much the same country we were at the beginning of WW2. The US had been largely isolationist, and the country had a recent memory of the horrors of trench warfare not many years before. Most WW1 vets were in their 40s-50s. The country was just coming out of a serious long term and debilitating depression. And the country was NOT all in favor of going off to war against the Japs and the Boche.
But then, unlike today...the media was not totally swayed by socialist ideology, though it was a very strong political mode in the US at that time. Wobblies, Unions, American Communist Party...and of course the antithesis..the German American Bund, etc.
People got their news from the radio or the paper, with the video of the day being newsclips at the movies. FDR was at the helm. He wasnt a particularly nice man either.
Shrug...as to democrat socialism, thats a given. Republican Fascism? Fascism is closer to the democrat line in the US, then the Republican agenda. Nanny State control of industry is not the typical plank of todays Republicans. It is of the Dems.
We do live in interesting times, but we will continue to survive quite well. This Amazing Experiment called the United States is in no danger of the times, just from enemies external to it, and they cannot destroy it, just annoy it.
Gunner
"A vote for Kerry is a de facto vote for bin Laden." Strider
N
Nick Hull
Or both conclusions were correct. Guilty people get framed too.
G
Gunner
Rampart in L.A. is a prime example
Gunner
That rifle hanging on the wall of the working-class flat or labourer's cottage is the symbol of democracy. It is our job to see that it stays there. - George Orwell
R
Richard Lamb
Nope, no score on Godwin. A passing reference to what the definition does NOT mean...
Socialism: 1) A social system in which the producers posess both political power and the means of producing goods.
That's from American Heritage. There has got to be a better definition around somewhere...
Richard
G
Gunner
Sure it does, but Ill let you slide this time.
Try these....
Definitions of SOCIALISM on the Web:
a theory or system of social organization by which the major means of production and distribution are owned, manages, and controlled by the government, by an association or workers, or the community as a whole
formatting link
an economic system in which the means of production are controlled by the state
formatting link
An economic and political system in which private property is abolished and the means of production (i.e., capital and land) are collectively owned and operated by the community as a whole in order to advance the interests of all. In Marxist ideology, socialism is considered an intermediate stage in the inevitable transformation of capitalism into communism. A socialist society is envisioned as being characterized by the dictatorship of the proletariat; the existence of a high degree of cooperation and equality; and the absence of discrimination, poverty, exploitation, and war. With the non-existence of private ownership, the private profit motive is eliminated from economic life. Consequently, market forces do not play a role in organizing the process of production. Instead, large-scale government planning is employed to ensure the harmonious operation of the process of production.
formatting link
A social system in which the means of producing and distributing goods are owned collectively and political power is exercised by the whole community.
formatting link
A term covering many belief systems that oppose the concentration of wealth and power that is a natural part of capitalism. Whereas capitalists emphasize freedom for the individual to possess private property, socialists emphasize the well-being of the community. They strive to achieve this through many methods, including public ownership, regulation, and state-sponsored social programs. Socialism has taken on many different forms throughout the world, with varying degrees of success. Some socialists favour a gradual move away from unrestricted capitalism and the maintenance of a democratic society; others favour force to overthrow capitalism and distribute wealth.
formatting link
The view that the government should own and control major industries pittsford.monroe.edu/jefferson/calfieri/economics/EcoGlossary.html
government ownership of the means of production; leads to economic stagnation due to a lack of competition, innovation and productivity (examples: postal service, transportation, civil courts, education)
formatting link
system in which the government controls production and distribution of goods and wealth in a country. web.isp.cz/jcrane/Glossary.html
(3 syl.). The political and social scheme of Robert Owen, of Montgomeryshire, who in 1816 published a work to show that society was in a wretched condition, and all its institutions and religious systems were based on wrong principles. The prevailing system is competition, but Owen maintained that the proper principle is co-operation; he therefore advocated a community of property and the abolition of degrees of rank. (1771-1858.) The Socialists are called also Owenites (3 syl.). In France the Fourierists and St. Simonians are similar sorts of communists, who receive their designations from Fourier and St. Simon (q.v.).
formatting link
economic theory or system in which production should be for the public good rather than private profit.
formatting link
n. a political and economic theory advocating collective ownership of the means of production, and collective control of distribution. It advocates use of coercive force by the civil government to attain the "ideal" of economic and social fairness and equality. In practice socialism always leads to an aristocracy which brutally enforces its "ideal" upon the rest of society.
formatting link
The attempted abolition of all privilege by restoring power entirely to the coercive agent behind privilege, the State, thereby converting capitalist oligarchy into Statist monopoly. Whitewashing a wall by painting it black.
formatting link
A kind of command economy in which the government owns and operates the main industries, while individuals own and operate less crucial industries. wps.prenhall.com/ca_ph_ebert_busess_3/0,6518,224378-,00.html
an economic system in which the people (government) own and operate the principle means of production. This means things such as communications, railroads, steel, oil, and so on instruction.blackhawk.tec.wi.us/ghoffarth/economicsglossary.htm
An economic system that stresses the varying degrees of government ownership and redistribution of wealth. schools.cbe.ab.ca/b836/curriculum/social/socialgloss.html
an economic system in which the government owns and operates basic industries but individuals own most businesses (See See page 10.) highered.mcgraw-hill.com/sites/0070898375/student_view0/chapter1/key_terms__amp__glossary.html
Philosophical approach to government that allows for public ownership of businesses.
formatting link
a political theory advocating state ownership of industry
formatting link
an economic system based on state ownership of capital
formatting link
That rifle hanging on the wall of the working-class flat or labourer's cottage is the symbol of democracy. It is our job to see that it stays there. - George Orwell
G
Gunner
I also found this one...
"There is no difference between communism and socialism, except in the means of achieving the same ultimate end: communism proposes to enslave men by force, socialism - by vote. It is merely the difference between murder and suicide." - Ayn Rand, from "Foreign Policy Drains U.S. of Main Weapons"
A
Alan Moore
Well, since the Democrats are no more socialist than the Republicans are fascist, I'd say you need to take a closer look at both parties and their candidates than you have.
They have a lot in common. Both represent the interests of the largest multinational corporations above all other interests, for example. The differences between the parties reflect in part differences of opinion among this constituency, and are in part merely an effort to, by adopting a public position, attract blocks of votes. Consider, in this regard, the number of places that the Republicans have come to dominate the legislature and in which gun control legislation has actually been repealed. Or look at the Democrats, and the number of places in which restrictions on abortion have actually been removed, and the procedure made available to those who need it.
Or just look at their candidates for president. Which party is proposing the wealthy son of a wealthy New England family?
Al Moore
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.