"Tim Shoppa" wrote in message news: snipped-for-privacy@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com... | [Chemical generators vs oxygen tanks] | > There are advantages and disadvantages to both. | > The Passenger Service Units (PSU's) are a complete | > module that are easily reconfigured with the | > airplane, but plumbed oxygen | > requires more hassle, obviously. | > Some folks don't like the plumbing all over the | > plane with pressurized oxygen, but it is lighter than | > all the generators, which are a bit hefty. | | Interesting. I would've suspected that pressurized oxygen would be | heavier. | | In any event, when I'm on an airplane I'm nervous enough that it's a | hurtling kerosene tank. Pressurized oxygen and plumbing, or chemical | oxygen generators, give me the heebie-jeebies. I would've thought that | the pressurized oxygen was heavier due to tankage but maybe the O2 | cylinders I see in hospitals/shops are way overdesigned compared to | aircraft weight standards. | | Now, smoking while on a hurtling kerosene tank that also has chemical | oxygen generators and/or pressurized O2, that does not strike me as the | right thing to do at all! It's not that I'm afraid of flying, it's | just all those risk factors being put in the same place. In the shops | I work (related to public transportation but generally not exposed to | the public) having any two of those four things in the same place | would have you shut down so quick by the safety people, and we aren't | even hurtling through the air! | | Tim.
The odds are firmly in favor of the flyer. I want to say 200 times more in your favor, or some similar figure. Why some idiots drive around with no seatbelts on yet refuse to fly in an airplane is completely beyond me. The fellow I knew that was worst about that actually built 747's with me! The deaths in aircraft usually happen at bunch at a time on rare occasions, not hundreds (or thousands, depending on your working area) _a day_ like in cars, and spread out all over the place, which we generally accept as normal. The FAA's REAL job, if you can believe it, is to simply encourage you to fly by creating the impression that airplanes are safer than driving. It's actually a tough mission, and to make the point, remember when some folks wanted children's car seats on airplanes for all kids? The FAA said no because it makes flying more expensive for the public, who would have to buy more tickets, so would be more likely to drive, thereby increasing the death toll. Get it? The odds of Flight 800 happening were so damn high they haven't been able to reproduce it in the lab, so all the explanation was is pure theory. The fix is to reduce the voltage inside the tanks to the fuel sending equipment (the pumps motors are actually outside the tank, with shafts going to the pumps) so that sparks were a million times less likely to occur, but the additional equipment is kinda heavy and expensive. The other option is inerting, common on military planes, but since commercial airlines have to make a profit, the weight and retrofit so far is pricey too, not to mention the systems don't work so great for that application. Bang for the buck. If it's expensive for the airlines, it'll be expensive for you too. When you can't afford to fly, you drive. When you drive, you increase your odds of dying by some 200 times. Ask yourself this question: In the US last year, how many people died in airplane accidents? How many died in car accidents? There you go.
Oh, and since jet fuel, diesel, and kerosene are pretty much one and the same, you can throw lit matches at the stuff all day and it won't light off. You have to pressurize it or get it really, really hot first. Not saying that doesn't happen in aircraft accidents, but if you poke around on the web at all the pictures of aircraft accidents, you won't see very many pictures of burnt planes as much as you will see bent, busted, broke, and dented planes of all sizes.