OT - Greek 737 plane crash

Aug 17, 2005 76 Replies

It's been happening for years with qualified planes, pilots and airports. Google cat3a.

The problem is that it costs lots of money to keep everything certified to do it. It's cost-effective and used all the time on high density bad weather routes like Paris to London.

The pilots aren't always fond of it as it takes away the most fun part of flying.

I disagree. I had the opportunity to fly a full motion 737 sim at America West airlines and took the controls while "in the air" with no instruction and landed the aircraft and taxiied it off the active. I was familar with the Phoenix airspace so I had good visual references to work with Only problem I had was finding the trim button so I delt with the heavy controls.

Didn't even bounce it with a slight crosswind programmed into the sim. Definitely not the same stress level as flying the real thing for the first time. Flaps, brakes, thrust reversers, and the nose control wheel aren't all that difficult to figure out.

I do have a PPL and experience in a bunch of 2 and 4 seaters. (Cessna, Piper, Beech, Dimona, L-39)

Hey if you can land one of these drunk, (Northwest and America West pilots.) I know I could land the real thing sober.

Bart

Bart D. Hull snipped-for-privacy@inficad.com Tempe, Arizona

Check

formatting link
my Subaru Engine Conversion Check
formatting link
Tango II I'm building.

Remove -nospam to reply via email.

Dan_Thomas snipped-for-privacy@yahoo.com wrote:

I think you missed it. They are very complex. They are computer controlled. They can land a 747 cargo plane in auto pilot. These planes are capable of being driven by a thinking person that can keep their head. There is fully capable people on the ground to help in a short time.

I have flown a C-47 - no flight school or anything. Took it on a long dog leg as one of the things to do with the captain in the co seat and the co taking time off. Those are like driving a tank in the air.

Martin

"Tim Shoppa" wrote in message news: snipped-for-privacy@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com... | [Chemical generators vs oxygen tanks] | > There are advantages and disadvantages to both. | > The Passenger Service Units (PSU's) are a complete | > module that are easily reconfigured with the | > airplane, but plumbed oxygen | > requires more hassle, obviously. | > Some folks don't like the plumbing all over the | > plane with pressurized oxygen, but it is lighter than | > all the generators, which are a bit hefty. | | Interesting. I would've suspected that pressurized oxygen would be | heavier. | | In any event, when I'm on an airplane I'm nervous enough that it's a | hurtling kerosene tank. Pressurized oxygen and plumbing, or chemical | oxygen generators, give me the heebie-jeebies. I would've thought that | the pressurized oxygen was heavier due to tankage but maybe the O2 | cylinders I see in hospitals/shops are way overdesigned compared to | aircraft weight standards. | | Now, smoking while on a hurtling kerosene tank that also has chemical | oxygen generators and/or pressurized O2, that does not strike me as the | right thing to do at all! It's not that I'm afraid of flying, it's | just all those risk factors being put in the same place. In the shops | I work (related to public transportation but generally not exposed to | the public) having any two of those four things in the same place | would have you shut down so quick by the safety people, and we aren't | even hurtling through the air! | | Tim.

The odds are firmly in favor of the flyer. I want to say 200 times more in your favor, or some similar figure. Why some idiots drive around with no seatbelts on yet refuse to fly in an airplane is completely beyond me. The fellow I knew that was worst about that actually built 747's with me! The deaths in aircraft usually happen at bunch at a time on rare occasions, not hundreds (or thousands, depending on your working area) _a day_ like in cars, and spread out all over the place, which we generally accept as normal. The FAA's REAL job, if you can believe it, is to simply encourage you to fly by creating the impression that airplanes are safer than driving. It's actually a tough mission, and to make the point, remember when some folks wanted children's car seats on airplanes for all kids? The FAA said no because it makes flying more expensive for the public, who would have to buy more tickets, so would be more likely to drive, thereby increasing the death toll. Get it? The odds of Flight 800 happening were so damn high they haven't been able to reproduce it in the lab, so all the explanation was is pure theory. The fix is to reduce the voltage inside the tanks to the fuel sending equipment (the pumps motors are actually outside the tank, with shafts going to the pumps) so that sparks were a million times less likely to occur, but the additional equipment is kinda heavy and expensive. The other option is inerting, common on military planes, but since commercial airlines have to make a profit, the weight and retrofit so far is pricey too, not to mention the systems don't work so great for that application. Bang for the buck. If it's expensive for the airlines, it'll be expensive for you too. When you can't afford to fly, you drive. When you drive, you increase your odds of dying by some 200 times. Ask yourself this question: In the US last year, how many people died in airplane accidents? How many died in car accidents? There you go.

Oh, and since jet fuel, diesel, and kerosene are pretty much one and the same, you can throw lit matches at the stuff all day and it won't light off. You have to pressurize it or get it really, really hot first. Not saying that doesn't happen in aircraft accidents, but if you poke around on the web at all the pictures of aircraft accidents, you won't see very many pictures of burnt planes as much as you will see bent, busted, broke, and dented planes of all sizes.

"Rex B" wrote in message news: snipped-for-privacy@inoli.com... | | Jon Elson wrote: | >> Not likely. The average airliner has so little in common with the | >> average lightplane that the pilot would just change the scene of the | >> crash. Airliner navigation systems are so complex that he wouldn't be | >> able to figure out where he was, much less get the thing configured and | >> lined up for a workable approach and landing, and things like gear and | >> flaps slats and spoilers and reverse thrust can keep two experienced | >> pilots plenty busy. Just figuring out how to disable the autopilot | >> might take time. | | It's my understanding that the newest airliners can land themselves | without pilot input. Is that true?

Yes and no. The system, ALS (I think,) automated landing system, requires special equipment on the ground. IIRC, Boeing has two of their fields certified by the FAA, Paine Field and Moses Lake in Washington state (Moses Lake is a big flight test spot for them) but it ain't cheap and so very few other airports have used it. It also requires special software be installed in system capable airplanes (meaning digital controls, not old stuff) that combine the inputs from many of the aircraft's system and fed into the autopilot. You have to have all your mechanical controls be operable by computer, which means it has to be fly by wire. No control cables or anything. Airbus' philosophy about flying is to let the computer make the decisions with "requests" from the pilot (hence some interesting accidents early on in the program) and Boeing's philosophy is to let the pilot be in control of the plane at all times, although the computers do help out a lot by assuming control of most systems when so directed. You can override the systems on any Boeing airplane just by moving the controls where you need them to go, unlike their competitor's planes which require you to remember where the "please let me have the plane back" button is.

Nothing new about blind or "hands off" Cat 3a landings. The first one at Heathrow was in 1972, long before fly-by-wire or extensive digital controls.

Since airplane travel is always over 5 miles, and statistically most accidents happen within 5 miles of home, that's not a realistic comparison :)

Weren't we talking Cub pilot, here? Ever been in a Cub? A Cub has a stick wioth nothing on it, rudder pedals, a throttle, a tach, an airspeed indicator, an altimeter, a magnetic compass, and lots of windows. Nothing more. The average Cub pilot isn't going to figure out how to set heading and altitude, and even if he did, the airliner is following much more than heading; it may be tracking a GPS bearing, an RNAV bearing, a VOR bearing, or it might be an inertial guidance system. An older airplane might even be tracking Loran or Omega. Further, resetting course doesn't get the airplane back on the ground. A pilot familiar with IFR procedures might have the best chance, if he can contact ATC and get vectors. And all this with a depressurized airplane at altitude. Not a simulator that someone else set up for a greenhorn, not a cruise leg with no other responsibilities, nothing so simple. We run a groundschoolcouse just to teach our students how to run the GPS in our light aircraft, and it takes a few hours to understand and learn how to get through the various screens and functions. On one radio. Find a computer with Microsoft's Flightsim 2004 or something and see how quickly you figure out how to work the stuff in a 737.

Dan

| > The odds are firmly in favor of the flyer. I want to say 200 times more | > in your favor, or some similar figure. Why some idiots drive around with no | > seatbelts on yet refuse to fly in an airplane is completely beyond me. The | > fellow I knew that was worst about that actually built 747's with me! | ( stuff snipped) | > Bang for the buck. If it's expensive for the | > airlines, it'll be expensive for you too. When you can't afford to fly, you | > drive. When you drive, you increase your odds of dying by some 200 times. | > Ask yourself this question: In the US last year, how many people died in | > airplane accidents? How many died in car accidents? There you go. | | Since airplane travel is always over 5 miles, and statistically most | accidents happen within 5 miles of home, that's not a realistic | comparison :)

However you want to look at it, but the FAA wants you to chose flying when you would otherwise make a choice between cars and planes.

Invalid comparison.

Give me the fatalities per hour of passenger exposure, planes vs cars and then we can talk. The numbers are about the same. Jim

airplane accidents? >How many died in car accidents? There you go.

I seem to remember a published figure of about 30,000 traffic fatalities per year in the U.S. This doesn't directly relate to aviation safety versus traffic safety, though, since there are many times more people in cars at any given time than there are in airplanes. How many miles did any of us travel in an airliner last year compared to the miles in a car or bus or truck? I'm in the aviation industry and we see fatality risk figures that look something like this: Private pilot in a lightplane: four times more dangerous than a car (about the same risk as crossing a busy city street in a crosswalk). Commercial pilot in a lightplane: Twice as safe as a car. Transport category aircraft (airlines): eleven times safer than a car. Still safer, but not by 200 times. Dan

The only true fly by wire surfaces on the 767 are the spoilers/speedbrakes. All other flt. control surfaces are conventionally operated by cables, bellcranks, etc. On a cat IIIa or b approach, the autopilots will disconnect with pilot input up to a certain point on the approach. After that, any force inputs to the control wheel will not cause a disconnect. He can't override the autopilot manually. He would have to disconnect at the a/p disconnect switch on the control wheel or knock down the engage handles. It's definitely a different philosophy than Airbus. And the right one, in my opinion. If better airplanes are built, Boeing will build them. And cat IIIa is not really a zero altitude and zero RVR landing. (Runway visual reference, how far can you see looking through the fog down the runway.) If the pilot is on a cat IIIa approach, he must have at least

700' RVR, (measured by instruments adjacent to the runway and called out to him by the tower), and must be able to see the runway at 50' radio altitude or he's got to go around and try again. Or divert to another airport. Cat IIIb is true 0 alt. and 0 rvr and provides nosewheel steering from the localizer radio beam down the runway. Cat IIIc is rollout guidance. The airplane will steer itself to the gate area. The airport has to be certified for all this and have small transmitters buried in the tarmac for guidance. I know Heathrow used to be setup for this. The only aircraft I ever worked on that was Cat IIIc certified was the Lockheed L-1011. They very rarely used it, however. That system was a bitch to maintain, but Lockheed sure built a good, solid airplane.

Garrett Fulton

Scarebus anyone?

"Hey, the rudder just ripped off the aircraft..."

Jim

How does that make it more relevant? Why not fatalities per mile flown/driven. I don't think you can ever really have a valid comparison. Let's just use fatalities per lifetime!!:)

Exactly. I can't imagine any pilot input to a Boeing, no matter how violent, causing pieces of the ship to break away. Eurotrash.

Garrett Fulton

Let's just use fatalities per lifetime!!:)

That'll work out pretty easy for everybody! One!

That is simple -- only one fatality per lifetime -- aircraft or automobile -- but not both in most cases.

I can understand *why* some people prefer driving to commercial air travel. They feel that they have more control of what happens. (Whether this translates to a greater chance of avoiding an accident is debatable, of course.)

As for why *I* drive, rather than use air travel these days:

1) I don't have to remove all the metal typically hanging from my belt and occupying my pockets. (Even my *shoes* are steel-toed safety boots, so they would trigger concerns with the safety inspectors.) 2) I don't have to deal with packing for shipping the audio recording equipment, including the rather expensive microphones, and have them subject to handling damage/pilfering by the "security" inspectors. If my travel were something like a vacation trip, and I did not have to carry along the tools which I commonly have, I might consider air travel. I *liked* flying -- I just hated the time at the airports, and that has gotten more and more onerous.

BTW This thread started out discussing the deaths of the pilots, flight crew and passengers on the Greek plane. It made me think of a scenario in a book which I read some years ago, in which a terrorist attempt was made to kill both the pilot and co-pilot by painting concentrated nicotine on the underside of some toggle switches which the crew would have to operate once they were airborne, and it was supposed to kill them before they landed. (As it turned out, for whatever reason, one of them never touched the switch with his bare hands. I forget whether he had gloves on, or simply the other was the only one who operated that switch.

According to a rather old Merk index, the LD50 (Lethal Dose in 50% of the animals tested) was 55 mg/kg orally in rats, and 1mg/kg IV in rats. There is no information on skin absorption in humans. I have heard of a spit from chewing tobacco killing a small frog or toad on which it lands, so there is some argument for this being possible. Enjoy, DoN.

| If my travel were something like a vacation trip, and I did not | have to carry along the tools which I commonly have, I might consider | air travel. I *liked* flying -- I just hated the time at the airports, | and that has gotten more and more onerous.

Same here. For some reason I discovered that the less I carried on board, both in clothes for my body as well as carry on the better the flight went for me. I had always brought more stuff to do than I had actual inclination to do. Now I just bring a fiction book and a clipboard or binder with some paper. Last time I flew I got everything in the carry on, which made getting in and out a breeze. If I get cold I just ask for a blanket; which is a lot easier than finding a place to stash a jacket. I also bring some Boeing stickers for kids around me, and some trinkets for the stewardesses, who treat you most excellent once they find out you work for Boeing and get nifty stuff from you. I have to make a special trip to the Boeing store before I fly. I hated waiting to fly even before 9/11, but it was the delays for all the assorted reasons I got bad headaches. Then I stopped giving a s*it about stuff like that, and with that attitude change and good meds I do much better!

And my personal favorite, the overwing seats on Southwest's 737's!

I think LORAN is gone now, doesn't exist anymore.

Jim

Still working, I think. The station in Central BC, Canada, was still standing last summer. Dan

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required