OT improving radio reception

Feb 23, 2005 173 Replies

I wouldn't worry about it. Radios usually have a small ceramic cap in series with any antenna terminal they might present.

If you can get by with one AM station, or don't mind tuning both the antenna and the radio when changing stations, I agree with Jim Rozen that a tuned loop might work quite well. It would certainly be easy to try. The larger the area and the higher it's located the better, but even a 3' square loop comprised of a dozen or more turns of hookup wire might provide surprisingly good results. It would help to have an oscillator with which to initially tune it, but if you want to try it I think several of us could calculate the right capacitance to start with if you describe the geometry and number of turns that might suit your situation.

The plane of the loop would be vertical and parallel with a line in the direction of the station.

Are we still talking about AM broadcast frequencies? At higher frequencies, unless you're taking advantage of the gain from a longwire, tuned antennas are likely to work better.

But it sounds like you're talking about a communications receiver (ham radio, I assume), and that's going to have a higher-Q front end than most broadcast band receivers. It's going to be much more sensitive to matching.

Try it at AM broadcast frequencies. I assume you have not tried tuning one of those with your transmitter.

BTW, I was all wet on the car capacitance to ground. I calculated it and it's a lot higher than I thought. Without knowing how the ground itself weighs in as a capacitor plate (probably pretty low), it would be around

500 - 800 pf if the car was parked on a grounded metal plate.

Now, about ground planes: What my 1968 edition of the ARRL Antenna Book says is that the function of a car body with a mounted whip, at low frequencies (they were talking about 160 - 80 m) is that of a capacitance to ground. The car doesn't function as a ground plane until you get up around 15 m.

-- Ed Huntress

Perhaps a less confusing way to state this is that receivers can often get away with using crappy antennae while xmtrs of any power cannot. It's a practical matter. Reciprocity still holds.

Receivers, particularly consumer receivers, can often get away with crappy antennae because they are often located where there is more than ample signal strength. Where signal strength is low, they need good antennae to work satisfactorily. Examples of good receiving antennae include TV antennae in fringe areas

Examples of crappy antennae used for transmitting are your keyless entry device and garage door openers.

Yes!!!! For broadcast band DX in the northernmost part of Michigan's upper peninsula we did use a long wire, but we also had a matching network on it and the receiver had a tuned RF stage. At night we could usually get Denver, Omaha, and Del Rio TX, often could get WGN in Chicago, WCCO in Mnpls, and WJR in Detroit.

Whoa, don't take it all that seriously, Jerry. I didn't take any offense. I'm rusty on a lot of things, and probably rustier than most on antennas. I just breezed through my old ARRL Antenna Handbook and I see there are a lot of things I forget.

In any case, hang in there. I'm the one who has to leave. Too much work staring me in the face. d8-)

-- Ed Huntress

Don sez: "At night we could usually get Denver, Omaha, and Del Rio TX, often could get WGN in Chicago, WCCO in Mnpls, and WJR in Detroit."

With some of those powerhouse stations you almost didn't need an antenna. I went in one of the US Stations broadcasting in (uncontrolled) Mexico; I think it was Del Rio, TX. Anyway, at first, the staion looked like an old fashioned ice plant with condensers on the roof. Come to find out, the condensers were for the cooling water coming off the plates of the final RF amplifiers.

Bob Swinney

I don't know if this crossed with my last message, but no apology is called for, Jerry. This is not exactly a church-social type of newsgroup. A little confrontation is involved in half of what gets said here. It's stimulating.

As for my grasp, it was once pretty good but is now subject to careful review -- whippersnapper.

-- Ed Huntress

Based on some rough calculations (because the average distance between ground and the bottom of the car is pretty tough to guess), that's about right -- if you're sitting on a grounded metal plate.

In fact, the apparent distance will be quite a bit greater over real ground, or the effective "plate" size of the ground will be much smaller, take your pick. But 100 pF or so of capacitance ought to couple the body pretty well.

-- Ed Huntress

Depends on what church you go to.

:^)

Jim

One of the hottest bc band receivers I have is a national SW-3.

Tuned RF in front, regenerative detector, and a single stage of audio. Three tubes, plug-in coils, lots of fun.

Jim

In article , Ed Huntress says... your transmitter.

That's what I calculated. I was using 10cm as the separation, and 10 m2 as the area - which winds up with about 1000 pf. Figuring that 0.08 = 0.1 of course. (g)

I also thumbed through my ARRL handbook last night. They always show the shield of the coax going to the car body at the antenna, and they always say that best place for lower frequency loaded antennas is still in the center of the roof.

The section on vertical antennas was also interesting - they said specifically that a large number of shorter radials (here they're discussing non-mobil antennas) is better than one or two long ones.

1/8 wave was mentioned as being just fine.

Jim

How about car-to-car, and then double the value? That would be a fair test.

Jim

The key point is that the only time a transmitting antenna makes an equally good receiving antenna is when you're transmitting and receiving on the same frequency, to the same location. In other words, in two-way communications on the same frequency.

That's just not the situation faced by most receiving antennas. There are other factors. For one, why would the transmitter and receiver want to see the same terminal impedance, unless you specifically designed them that way?

Note that I said that a good transmitting antenna will make a good receiving antenna, but not necessarily the other way around. I didn't say that a good transmitting antenna WILL NOT make a good receiving antenna.

-- Ed Huntress

Jim, it's NOT a ground plane. It doesn't couple to the radiator like a ground plane, it isn't large enough to reflect as a ground plane, and it isn't even at RF ground potential.

As you said, it's part of an unbalanced dipole, one end of which is capacitively coupled to ground. That's not a ground plane.

-- Ed Huntress

Ever see photos of the receiving station out on long island, the one that accompanied the Alexanderson alternator transmitting station?

For a while they were the only reliable communication with europe, and ran on about 100 kc. or so. They used long wire antennas, (which you probably know are sensitive off their *ends*) in an a switchable array shaped likes spokes in a wheel.

I think one reason that interest in bc band antennas has waned is economic. The notion of a "50Kw clear channel" station is anathema to broadcasting today. If there's only one station that covers a huge area, one can only sell one unit of advertising to it.

If that area is broken up into smaller pieces, each with a station targeted to that area, then they can collect N times the amount of ad revenue!

AM broadcast band is slowly being driven into the ground. Back when I was a boy (back when dinosaurs roamed the earth as my daughter says...) I recall hearing actual *music* on am radio. Eventually they're going to petition the FCC to eliminate am broadcast band service and replace it with something with a much more limited range in the same frequency slot. Just a SWAG.

Jim

For years adapters were sold, which contained a small capacitor, which screwed into a light socket - with a terminal on the outside. The idea was to hook your radio's antenna terminal to that socket, and the ground of the radio to a good water pipe ground.

The wiring in the house wasn't the 'car body' but rather one end of the dipole antenna, with the run of conductor to the ground being the other side.

The analogy is pretty good - in both cases there's rf voltage developed at the connection between two extended conductors.

In the house, it's between the wiring connection and the ground connection.

In the car, it's between the whip and the car body (or ground plane for those who prefer to think of it that way).

Both have short, random length conductors which present an untuned short dipole.

Jim

Yes, that sounds right. I was mistaking it with open wire line.

Sorry for the confusion.

Jim

gasp...chortle..chuckle...ROFLMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It's better to be a red person in a blue state than a blue person in a red state. As a red person, if your blue neighbors turn into a mob at least you have a gun to protect yourself. As a blue person, your only hope is to appease the red mob with herbal tea and marinated tofu.

(Phil Garding)

That was XERF. They'd admit to 250KW, wink wink.

Interesting story at

formatting link

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required