OT - Rotations of a low tire?

Aug 18, 2005 50 Replies

An inward wave doesn't seem likely on a tire that's anywhere near to normal inflation: that would mean the tire tread lifting off the road; but the air pressure inside is pressing the tire tread down onto the road. Even if the tire is only at 15 psi, with a contact patch of several tens of square inches that's still a lot of force. For the tire to lift off the road in the middle is plausible for a completely flat tire, which is where someone who posted to this thread observed it happening; but it's different if the tire is just low, not flat.

The nitpicker in me says that the tread will certainly compress, even if the belt doesn't, since the tread is outside the belt and is normally of a larger radius, yet as the two go over the contact patch, they are flattened out to the same length, or rather, to be more precise, to the same (infinite) radius. But this happens even with a tire at normal pressure, and happens about the same amount, since the initial radius is almost the same, and so is the final (infinite) radius.

To address your real question, the steel belt is prestressed by the tire's air pressure. For it to compress much, it'd have to lose all that prestress. Then it'd have to buckle -- which the individual wires in the belt are restrained from doing by the rubber surrounding them and binding them together. Either the rubber would have to disintegrate, or the tread as a whole would have to buckle. It can't buckle downward into the road, because the road is hard, so it would have to buckle up off the road, which gets us back to the question of whether the tire lifts up off the road in the middle of the contact patch; as mentioned above, I don't think this is likely for the sorts of tire pressures which you'd like to catch and report to the driver via an automated system of the type that started this thread.

Much as I like conservation-of-energy type arguments, they are made inapplicable here by the energy loss that heats up the tire. The actual torque at the axle is going to be greater than the number yielded by your above formula, because the torque at the axle must also provide the energy that goes into heating the tire.

The basic situation seems to be this:

-- The tire can't slip on the rim; one revolution of the tire always means one revolution of the rim.

-- At the middle of the tire contact patch, the tire wants to move the wheel at the angular speed omega given by the formula omega = v/r, where r is the distance from the axle to the road, and v is the car's speed.

-- At the very front of the tire contact patch, the tire wants to move the wheel at approximately omega = v/r0, where r0 is the distance from the axle to the front of the tire contact patch, which is about the normal radius of the wheel.

The two parts of the tire are thus fighting each other: each wants to move the wheel at a different angular velocity. The resulting angular velocity will be between the two figures, and there'll be scrubbing of the tire against the road, with the front of the contact patch trying to go faster over the ground, but slipping backwards, and the middle of the contact patch trying to go slower over the ground, but slipping forwards.

(Some of the people in this thread have been arguing for omega=v/r; others have been arguing for omega=v/r0; well, you're not the only ones; the tire is arguing with itself too.)

Sharp eyes will have noticed that there's an "approximately" in my above argument for omega=v/r0. That's largely because the tire tread is hitting the ground at an angle; that's really a formula for the velocity of a point on the tread just before it hits the ground, not just after. The correction factor for this is roughly cos(theta), where theta is the angle between vertical and the line between the axle and the front of the contact point: really the formula should be more like

omega = v*cos(theta) / r0,

except even that isn't correct, since it's based on the approximation that the tread makes a perfect circle interrupted only where it touches the ground, where it's perfectly flat. Still, it's not too far off; and for small theta, cos(theta) is approximately equal to one, yielding the approximation-to-an-approximation formula omega=v/r0.

From the frame of reference of the axle, r sweeps out a circle. The shape the tire assumes where it's not contacting the road has no effect on the velocity of the vehicle - it's irrelevant.

Huh? r is a function of pressure and I never said otherwise. I assumed it was a given that the pressure in the tire would not vary as a function of angular position.

In the case of the tracked vehicle r is the distance from the axle to the surface of the track that contacts the road. In other words, assuming rigid track and wheel, r is the pitch radius of the drive wheel plus the distance from the pitch line of the track to the driving surface.

I don't know how many more ways to say it. The car isn't bouncing up and down as the tire rotates - r is constant; from the axle's frame of reference r sweeps out a circle; the only propelling force is applied perpendicular to r at surface of the road; the formulae for circular motion are applicable.

Plug some numbers into this calculator, it will agree with my model.

Don, if your following, I'll hopefully get a chance to respond to you tomorrow night.

Ned Simmons

R sweeps a circle of circumference 2*pi*r per revolution of the axle. The peripheral length of the tread is greater than 2*pi*r, but the same spot on the tread is in contact with the pavement each revolution. Must be some wrinkles in the tread?

(snip)

No. The part of the tread in contact with the ground doesn't move relative to the ground (if it isn't mud), so the r there is the pitch radius of the (circular) drive wheel. Imagine a tread all laid out rather than wrapped around the wheel. The drive wheel would be riding on stationary tread that is laying on the ground surface. Making the tread thicker wouldn't make the vehicle go faster.

This is about as plain as it can be. Jeff, would you hand out those DNRs for those who can't understand this?

formatting link
Want more? Google for tire traction wave.

All sounds reasonable to me.

I was assuming a lossless tire, which I don't believe invalidates the argument.

Do the trig and I think you'll find that the horizontal component of omega * r0 is exactly equal to omega * r .

Ned Simmons

? x?VÛrÛ6}çWìS??lg?iÇÎ???ÓI2±¦~??%?­|}Ï?Y?Y" `/g?å¥Ó[º?+aKSð??æå£6Ó{GËn?Ñét9¶ôôää9??=zv?

In article , Norman Yarvin wrote: :The basic situation seems to be this: : : -- The tire can't slip on the rim; one revolution of the tire : always means one revolution of the rim. : : -- At the middle of the tire contact patch, the tire wants to : move the wheel at the angular speed omega given by the formula : omega = v/r, : where r is the distance from the axle to the road, and v is : the car's speed. : : -- At the very front of the tire contact patch, the tire wants to : move the wheel at approximately : omega = v/r0, : where r0 is the distance from the axle to the front of the tire : contact patch, which is about the normal radius of the wheel.

I'm going to pick up on the words "wants to" in the above. We are dealing with an elastic system (the tire sidewalls), so there is no requirement that the speed of a point on the periphery of the tire is always given by (omega * r), where omega is the angular speed of the hub and r is a variable that changes as the point moves in its non-circular path. Indeed, I postulate that omega at the periphery of the tire is not a constant, but in the region of contact with the road is higher than the angular speed of the hub. The only constraint is that, integrated around one complete revolution, the average value of omega at the periphery equals omega of the hub (i.e., there is no slippage of the tire on the rim).

Conveniently, this invalidates everyone else's caclulations to date, so I can smugly wave my hand and ride off into the sunset, at least until such time as someone comes up with evidence that the angular position of a point on the periphery of an underinflated tire is indeed fixed relative to the hub.

Hmm, I was imagining that factor wouldn't cancel, but you're right: it does. Even if there's a bulge in the tire, making r0 greater than the original radius of the tire, it still does. At any point on the ground plane (assuming the ground to be flat), the horizontal component of the rotational velocity vector is the same. So my above-quoted explanation is wrong.

There's still the problem of the tread having to make one complete revolution for every complete revolution of the rim, though. If the angular velocity of every piece of the tread were constant, then what would have to happen would be that just as the tread hit the ground, it would compress in length by a factor of cos(theta), and stay compressed by that factor until it lifted off the ground. But really the tread length is rather incompressible, due to the steel belt. So the angular velocity can't be constant: instead of the radial reinforcing cords staying purely radial at all times, they must deviate from being radial as they go over the contact patch: they must become, in angular terms, more divergent from each other, although no farther apart in absolute terms. The sidewall then has to flex to accomodate this.

Since the motion of the tire isn't a pure rotation, the formula v=omega*r doesn't apply in the first place.

This is about where I give up trying to juggle the variables in my head, and think in terms of writing a computer program.

It's not necessary for anybody to have analyzed this in detail: even the guys developing the system might just have noticed that the wheel ran at a different rate when the tire pressure was low, and that the value was significant enough to be seen over the noise. But the original poster to this thread seems to have been right that the change can't have been huge.

Yes, I caught that "behind" the tire thing also. I was positive I remembered the wave being in front of the tire. Dug into my notes; couldn't find the photo but found the notes. It was the right rear wheel of a 1962 Pontiac on a dyno. Perhaps the drive/free-rolling wheels are opposite. One other possibility is because the tire wasn't belted.

Sorry I haven't come back to this sooner, as I'm sure everyone is on tenterhooks anticipating a resolution , but I've worked about 30 hours in the last couple days, and got an afternoon's sailing in to boot.

Or perhaps not complicated enough. Rather than continuing with the speculative arguments I poked around a bit and found info that was either overly simplistic, or complicated by analyses of traction, drag, stability, and handling. This quote, from the description of Matlab function...

...is the most concise explanation I found.

********************************************************** The Tire block models the tire as a rigid-wheel, flexible- body combination in contact with the road. The model includes only longitudinal motion and no camber, turning, or lateral motion. At full speed, the tire acts like a damper, and the longitudinal force Fx is determined mainly by the slip. At low speeds, when the tire is starting up from or slowing down to a stop, the tire behaves more like a deformable, circular spring. The effective rolling radius re is normally slightly less than the nominal tire radius because the tire deforms under its vertical load." **********************************************************

I haven't found anything that's definitive on the relationship between what I've been calling r (the height of the axle above the ground) and what is usually referred to as re, the effective rolling radius. As best as I can tell r and re are close to equal at rest, and re increases with speed. r apparently increases with speed as well; whether it increases at the same rate as re is not clear to me.

Mark's Handbook has a table that lists the free diameter of, and the number of revs/mile made, by several sizes of common auto tires. It indicates that the effective radius of the tires listed is from around 1/4" to 1/2" smaller than the free radius of an unloaded tire. These figures are at highway speed and would presumably be greater if measured at low speeds.

This calculator agrees closely with the table in Mark's...

This paper details several tire models...

formatting link
The model that is detailed starting on p.27 has some pertinent info.

Ned Simmons

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required