Should I change to 1 PH motor or by converter for 3 ph motor
Nov 14, 2007 10 Replies
P
PeterM
I just got an older surface grinder that has a real new 1 hp 3 ph motor. I don't have 3 ph and I'm wondering if I should just buy another motor with a
1 ph, or should I buy the converter. I was told that with the converter I will lose about 1/3 of the rated hp. Any advise is appreciated....Peter
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
K
Karl Townsend
You want a VFD for that grinder. Dealers Electric or Automation Direct, both are good places to order from.
Karl
I
Ignoramus9314
With a rotary phase converter, or an electronic variable frequency drive, you will not lose any rated HP.
i
N
Nick Mueller
Q: And why? A: A 3ph runs much smoother. Something you want for a grinding wheel. Q: But ... A: ... you also can change cutting speed. Now buy a VFD!
Nick
J
Jim Wilkins
A replacement 1 phase motor may or may not increase vibration and cause visible patterning in the ground surface. If you use the grinder to sharpen tools you won't even notice.
I bought a VERY worn Delta Toolmaker for $50 plus $50 for the mag chuck, put a 1 phase TEFC Brazilian motor on it and lived happily ever after, but I wouldn't use it for a paying job unless the customer was a mechanical engineer who understood and accepted it.
Jim Wilkins
Hey Nick, "Once upon a time" is "Es war einmal", but what is "lived happily ever after"? ... froelich immer wieder? Yeah, we learn German and Russian fairy tales as kids.
P
PeterM
N
Nick Mueller
"Und wenn er nicht gestorben ist, dann lebt er heute noch". That's how the stories end.
Nick
T
Tony
It depends on several factors and you don't supply enough information.
What make/model is the grinder, and can it easily accept a inexpensive replacement motor?
Do you think theres a chance you will need to run more 3 phase equipment?
G
GeoLane at PTD dot NET
"If he isn't dead, then he's still living today" is the literal translation. Is that really the sense it's intended to convey?
and why in the world do they sing Bist Du Bei Mir at weddings here in the US when it's a funeral hymn.
RWL
B
Bob
Entirely appropriate from a bachelor's point of view......................... Bob
N
Nick Mueller
That's OT now (for the second time). I've sent you an eMail.
Nick
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.