I've got an American design for a gantry crane. Very nice design by all accounts but it's all in US steel specifications. Most are easily translated but the main RSJ (to use the generic term) is speciifed as a "6" 12.5 lb/ft beam". Machinerys Handbook fleshes out the detail but such an animal doesn't exisit in modern UK standards. The nearest that I get is a 178x102 beam at 19kg/m.
formatting link
The big question is whether the single point load capacity of the two beams is comparable over a 10ft span (note the mix of imperial and metric in my thinking - a characteristic of my age).
Can anyone who was awake in those classes on beam strength care to offer an opinion?
You can compare any beam, if you have its "areal momentum" (hope that's your term). Its dimension is m^4 (or mm^4). Bigger values denote stiffer beams. You should find the values for any beam (and maybe need to make a conversion imperial/metric).
Not I, but I would like to butt in with a related question.
I want to put a runway beam aong the length of my workshop, mainly for loading chucks & heavy jobs onto the big lathe. It'll probably never be loaded to more than 100Kg, but the transverse steel beams at that point will easily take half a ton & I have a half ton chain block and a beam trolley, so might as well design it to that capacity. The beams are 3m/10' apart. Suggestions please for a suitable beam section?
Thanks
Tim
Dutton Dry-Dock Traditional & Modern canal craft repairs Vintage diesel engine service
I have a 5" x 3" x 3/8" wall, U shaped beam laid on it back. One end sits on the wall at the back of the lathe between the rafters and the other end sits on top of a Bridgeport fixed head series I mill. Probably 8 foot span. Given that sitting on it's back isn't the best position, the Bridgeport mill/drill wasn't made as a prop and the block and tackle is secured by a wrap of chain and a bolt can the experts work out what load this isn't supposed to carry.
At the moment the biggest rotor it's had to lift is only about 1/2 a ton.
Oh forgot to mention it's the dark gray model Bridgy.
Also forgot to mention, any chance of an answer before Monday as there's a rotor in the lathe at the moment and it would be nice to know if I'm safe before I take it out Monday, If not I'll get Gert to lift it out .
Thanks for that, I'd envisaged needing something a bit heavier & will be pleased if I don't.
There are differences between 'Joists' and 'Universal Beams', I don't think many sizes of 'joist' are made now. I should think a UB of equivalent size to an RSJ rated for 1.45 ton would do my job quite adequately, though.
What about John's 'Gert saver', then?
Cheers Tim
Dutton Dry-Dock Traditional & Modern canal craft repairs Vintage diesel engine service
The other thing to bear in mind is that RSJs have tapered flanges; UBs have parallel flanges. A girder trolley will run better on one than the other.
The link Charles posted is really all you need. The specific link he shows pulls up a table of section sizes and data. The next 'tab' on the page is titled 'bending'; this gives you the allowable moment for any particular section size. For larger spans, torsional buckling is the limiting factor.
All that I need to do now is find an 8ft 178x102 beam at a sensible price. Pity the price of steel has risen so much lately. Should have done this 2 or 3 years ago!
Our local scrappie keeps various secondhand rsj's etc in a pile and sells by the foot, look at the seventh picture down:
formatting link
I'll be in there tomorrow, if you want I'll ask the question. We tend to give our steel scrap to them for nothing, so we can always ask a favour in the future. Nearly a ton of steel scrap already this last week and half a ton of transformers (nothing useful for you folks) we did take some money for the transfomers...:-))
Peter
-- Peter A Forbes Prepair Ltd, Luton, UK snipped-for-privacy@easynet.co.uk
Thanks. I think that I might have sorted a decent scrappie but he's not sure if he has a suitable beam.He does have some heavy square stuff that I'm after though. Since you're in there and he has something please ask.
We've known them for many years, and have always treated them as we would like to be treated ourselves. Much of the scrap railway stuff went in for free, but we always got a proper ticket for it which was all our customers wanted.
It's handy to have a wander round with the camera occasionally, and we do get a few bits and pieces there when we need them, and we usually pay for them, but at a better rate than someone 'off the street'.
Just to have somewhere to take metal scrap is useful for us, especially as so much of the 1950's and 1960's stuff from the railways and electricity boards is at its end of life now. Peter
-- Peter A Forbes Prepair Ltd, Luton, UK snipped-for-privacy@easynet.co.uk
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.