ARM: Review - Academy 1/72 Scale Dragon Wagon

Kit Review: Academy 1/72 Scale WWII Ground Vehicle Set 7 Kit No.
13409; U. S. Tank Transporter Dragon Wagon; 217 parts in olive drab
styrene; price US$27.00
Advantages: first kit of this subject in this scale; parts breakdown
offers a myriad of options for finishing the model; can be turned into
a show-stopper with some effort
Disadvantages: tires not spot on; some parts (e.g. windows) not
provided; directions do not highlight the kit's engineering
Rating: Highly Recommended
Recommendation: for all small-scale US Armor fans (WWII and Korea)
The big tank retrievers that developed during WWII have always
fascinated modelers, primarily as were very large and "bitty" - lots
of things hanging off them and details tucked into just about every
available niche or slot that could be found. The US M25 "Dragon Wagon"
with its massive armored M26 tractor and M15 semitrailer was probably
the best example of this until the German Faun "Elefant" appeared in
the late 1960s.
For many years the only kits available of this beast were the
Peerless Max one in nominal 1/35 scale and the ROCO one in HO, both of
which basically came out in the 1960s. About ten years ago, Tamiya
came out with a totally "in your face" kit of the Dragon Wagon in 1/35
which while not cheap was a stunning example of the kit-maker's art
and found a lot of homes with modelers.
Academy continues its nice new series on what it calls "Ground
Vehicle Sets" (apparently in an attempt to convert aircraft modelers
in 1/72 to armored vehicles - the armor modelers are the "faithful"
here and need no converting!) with a very well done kit of the Dragon
Wagon. It provides the standard version - the armored M26 cab and not
the later M26A1 "soft" cab - with the M15 semitrailer.
Unlike the other sets this one just provides the Dragon Wagon - no
other vehicles or accessories come in the kit, but on the other hand
in 1/72 this is a BIG model. But as it is 1/72, modelers should not
expect to see the same level of detail that Tamiya used to set the
standard.
The model is well laid out and as noted above the kit is better
engineered than the directions would have you to believe. All of the
doors and armored panels on the cab are separate and may be posed, but
be advised there are ejection pin marks on the inner faces of the
panels. Unlike the big kit, the cab of this one comes in four parts
and not one. The interior provides seats, several of the lever
controls, and other details. Serious modelers will find plenty of room
to add detail though as this cab is roomy and as noted can be opened
up. The cab has a number of separate parts to include tow bars and a
hip ring for the machine gun. A single-piece M2HB and a separate ammo
can complete the cab roof details.
The chassis consists of a backbone frame with add-on frame extenders
and all of the primary and auxiliary winch details. Drive details are
well done, but for some reason Academy made the tires far too square-
shouldered and these will need some sanding to get the right rounded
shape to them. The winches are nicely detailed and the only part which
is greatly simplified is the "strongback" assembly (here part A6)
which could be erected on the Tamiya kit for towing or using the
tractor as a wrecker. A6 is a single part with the "strongback" folded
down into stowed position around the fifth wheel.
The trailer is simplified compared to the Tamiya one and as noted
Academy does not even bother to point out options such as having the
ramps (C42/C43) up or down, showing just the "up" position. Ditto the
"landing gear" (Parts D21, C49 and C50) which is also only shown
retracted; however this will take more work to install in the "down"
position. Also shown in the "up" position are the rear wheel guards
(parts C33-C41, D11) which are stowed on the gooseneck of the
trailer.
The model comes with three different finishing options, all in olive
drab: all are listed as "unknown" and two are for France 1944 and one
is 1994 - no clue if it is a restored vehicle or not. The second one
clearly shows markings for "465-O EVAC 11" which should be the 465th
Ordnance Battalion, which would be a higher echelon unit and not a
divisional one.
Overall Academy has provided a sound basis for an outstanding model,
and I am sure that Eduard will continue its dovetailing to provide a
good set of brass for this kit to really bring out its nicer features.
Thanks to Bob Lewen of MRC for the review sample.
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne
Loading thread data ...
Question - I enjoy reading your reviews, but always wondered how do you calculate the ratings (which seem to tend toward the 'Highly Recommended', but that may be because you've been reviewing good kits lately).
Reply to
Sir Ray
Simple.
Highly Recommended -- model builds up into what it says it is, has few dimensional or technical errors, and has a decent level of detail out of the box
Recommended -- model can be built up to what it claims to be but has some errors or goofs that require the modeler to correct them, is missing some key items or components, and needs work to be built to an acceptable level of accuracy.
Recommended with Reservations -- model will take a lot of work to correct, as it has numerous errors or wrong parts for its specific version, dimensional or detail problems, but may be the only kit of this particular subject so options are limited.
Not Recommended - model is terrible, incorrect beyond repair, or more commonly today a bad copy of a good kit in an attempt to get a cheap kit to market (e.g. Trumpeter's T-72M1 or Academy's original Sheridan kits).
The model reviews I write are aimed at intermediate modelers with some skills at basic conversion or scratchbuilding and are not as hyper- critical as some advanced modelers to missing bolts, rivets, seams, or other items which may or may not seriously detract from a kit.
Hope that helps!
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne
works for me. i've bought 4 kits predicated on your reviews and all 4 had no surprises and built up as reviewed.
Reply to
someone
Not quite the first kit in this scale, but the first injection molded kit of the M26 n 1/72 scale. Planet Models was the first using cast resin. Forces of Valor will be next with a built/panted model.
Cheers,
Tom
Reply to
maiesm72
Ah, now I understand. Thanks...
Reply to
Sir Ray
Tom,
Roger that, was just sticking to injection molded styrene or would have a bunch of others as well!
Cookie Sewell
Reply to
AMPSOne

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.