ARM: Review - Trumpeter 1/35 scale 2S1 Self-Propelled Howitzer

Kit Review: Trumpeter 1/35 scale Kit No. 05571; Russian 2S1 Self-Propelled Howitzer; 937 parts (588 in light brown styrene, 265 grey styrene, 72 etche
d brass, 11 clear styrene, 1 twisted brass wire); retail price US$62.99
Advantages: very highly detailed model of this widely used weapon;
Disadvantages: track hyper-detailing will annoy and frustrate many modelers ; etched brass swim vanes will be fiddly to assemble
Rating: Recommended (Highly Recommended less tracks)
Recommendation: for all Soviet artillery fans
    In the late 1950s the Soviet Army realized that its artillery weapons were quickly becoming obsolete, with only 152mm howitzers mounted on a self-pro pelled chassis and an obsolete 76mm system in the SU-76. As there was a who lesale overhaul of the Main Artillery Directorate (GAU) going on to become the Main Missile and Artillery Directorate (GRAU), studies began to create a new family of self-propelled artillery to support tank and motorized rifl e units.
     This materialized in a new family of self-propelled artillery weapons, ea ch having a designator and a ?Flower? project name:
    2S1     Gvozdika    122mm self-propelled howitzer for ground forces     2S2    Fialka         122mm self-propelled howitzer for airborne forces (not built)     2S3    Akatsiya    152mm self-propelled howitzer for ground forces     2S4    Tyul?pan    240mm self-propelled mortar for High-Powered Artillery     2S5    Giatsint    152mm self-propelled gun for Army/Front level artillery     2S7    Peon        203mm self-propelled gun for High-Powered Artillery
    The Gvozdika (carnation) was designed to additionally be amphibious to kee p up with tanks and the new BMP infantry fighting vehicle and so it was lar ge and spacious to provide the necessary buoyancy needed. Prototypes entere d testing in 1969 and the gun was accepted for service in 1970, with produc tion commencing in 1972 and running through 1991 at the Kharkov Tractor Fac tory.
    The 2S1 was fielded in sets of 18 to motorized rifle regiments up until 19 80, when it was also supplied to tank regiments. Thus a motorized rifle or tank division in the Soviet Army eventually had 72 of these guns in service . While it was dropped in 1991 as the Russians felt 122mm was too small a c aliber for current use, many of the guns may now be rebuilt as the 2S34 sel f-propelled 120mm weapon which is capable of functioning as a mortar, howit zer or antitank weapon.
    Some 34 different nations have used the 2S1, and the first and only time U S forces came into contact with it was during DESERT STORM in 1991 while in Iraqi service. While these were good weapons, in Iraqi hands they were not up to the task and were either counter-batteried out of existence or captu red. APG used to have one from the 51st Iraqi Mechanized Division on displa y when the museum was there.
    In 1999 SKIF released a kit of the 2S1 consisting of 206 parts in grey sty rene, black vinyl and etched brass. While it was one of the better SKIF kit s, it suffered from poor tracks, soft details, and the fact it was based on an early production vehicle missing many of the features found on more com mon ones.
    Trumpeter is now doing an entire series of Soviet/Russian artillery pieces , and has followed its lovely 2S3 and BM-21 kits with the 2S1 (the 2S19 is to follow in 2014). Unlike the SKIF kit, this one has a lot of nice, crisp details and can be considered anything but ?soft? in that area.
    All of the hatches on the vehicle are provided as separate parts, but ther e is not one wit of an interior to be found. At least the crew hatches have internal details, so an aftermarket interior only needs to cover turret, e ngine and such.          But the details on this kit, while crisp, are tiny to minuscule! The track s along each have two tiny separate teeth, so the majority of parts in the kit are tracks. This is a bit of overkill on the part of Trumpeter, and wil l probably make anyone selling aftermarket tracks very happy. Likewise, the swimming vanes for the rear of the hull are all formed from etched brass. While far superior to the mediocre SKIF ones they are going to be dicey to assemble as there is very little ?foot? for the parts to be attached, e ven using solder. While Trumpeter did a nice job of them, they should have offered a slightly easier option in styrene. (Or, build it as Iraqi where m any of the units jettisoned them as irrelevant.)
    Construction is quite conventional and other than the aforementioned swim vanes etched is kept to a minimum and used where needed.
    The turret shell, lower hull and upper hull are single parts and all show signs of slide molding with great detail capture and representation.          There are some options on the model. The option in Step 5 is for air clean ers set for swimming (raised) or normal (lowered); the directions do not sh ow the raised ones installed.
    Parts C5 and C6 are the front swim vanes and are in styrene, but the direc tions again do not note in Step 8 and Step 11 that 8 is installed for use a nd 11 is stored for normal movement! They do show empty or full racks in St ep 11, but pick one or the other.
    Decals are neatly done and the finishing directions cover five different g uns: A, B, D, and E appear to be Soviet ones with B in ?Guards? finish, but D is an Iraqi one marked for the 21st Artillery Regiment ((Battalion)) , 3rd ?Saladin? Armored Division, Iraqi army 1991. Note that it should have markings front and rear so half of them are missing.
    Overall, other than the overwrought tracks this is a lovely kit and will m ore than fill the bill for a popular and widely used SP howitzer.
Cookie Sewell
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload

Polytechforum.com is a website by engineers for engineers. It is not affiliated with any of manufacturers or vendors discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.