N-Scale--Atlas vs Kato vs ?

In N-Scale locomotives, non-DCC, which do you believe has the best quality and features?


Reply to
Loading thread data ...

At this point in time I would say that all those locos are very close in quality. I'm speaking here about diesel (or non-steam) locos.

Kato used to be superior to all ther others but in the last few years Kato's quality has gone down a bit while others almost caught up to Kato.

Basically Kato, Life-Like, Atlas and I think Model-Power and even others are all using the same low-friction mechanism design. It was originated by Kato but all the others copied it. Not sure about Bahmann new diesels (haven't seen one yet).

While design is similar, the overall quality and tolerances of Kato is still a bit better than the rest. But for all practical purposes, they are all very good.

I'm especially impressed with Life-Like and Model Power quality. They have become viable manufacturers of quality N scale locos (not just cheap and poor running toy trains).


Reply to
Peter W.

I haven't tried any Atlas locos yet, but based on my experience:

Bachmann Spectrum: Close to Kato in terms of appearance and running quality. Try before you buy, though. I had a drive bogie housing fall off in my hand once.

Kato: Very nice. Very smooth, and finely-detailed.

Life-Like Proto-N: Looks good, but doesn't run too well - my Proto-N loco requires half-throttle to start, then takes off like a rocket. And it's a switcher.

Reply to
Danny TB

The detail on my (first release) LL GP20s is very nice, and was probably ahead of most of the pack when they were released. They perform better than most of my locos. In fact, I even (briefly) considered junking the mechs under my Atlas GP7s and replacing them with GP20 mechs. From what I've read however, the latest release GP20s don't pull as well as the earlier ones.


*** Free account sponsored by SecureIX.com *** *** Encrypt your Internet usage with a free VPN account from
formatting link
Reply to

This is a LL Proto-N SW8. Might just be a one-off. I'm taking the motor out this weekend to see what can be done to improve performance.

Reply to
Mr Daniel Bella

I do not think they have enough weight.. I had 2 and I replaced them with Atlas MP15 units. Both LL units did not pull well. Ran smooth but just did not pull cars. I have LL SD-7 units and like them. rest of my units are split Kato or Atlas. and I have 2 Minitrix U28C that run great. units have to be 30 years old.

Reply to
Clarence Allenby

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.