engine weight/power/size comparisons

This is related to my other thread "need engine recommendation". I have a collection of FP engines, several in each size from 10 to 60,
leaving out only the 35. I recently built two identical Small Wonders (15 size parasol wing from RCM plans) for myself and a friend. I put a 15 FP on mine and a 400 MaH NiMH battery. My friend put the MDS 18 and a standard NiCad Rx pack in his.
I don't like to spend money, so I don't go nuts on small radio equipment. Both of us used three standard servos for these planes. My plane weighs 36 oz ready to fly, and his weighs 44. I'll estimate an extra ounce or three for his aluminum gear and axles compared to my wire gear. I weighed the batteries, and his weighs 2.5 oz more than mine. The rest will have to be attributed to the engine. Although the size of the head and cylinder look the same, the MDS has a bigger carburetor, bigger muffler, and ball bearings. You may think that it's all the same either way, but that's just about a 20% difference in weight. My plane has the same rate of climb and is noticeably more maneuverable and less oily. His plane flies great, but I prefer mine.
I really liked the MDS, though. It was quiet, very user friendly, and it spun an 8x6 prop nicely. I'm thinking that maybe it would be a fine choice for a 20 size plane, but clearly it was out of my range for the 15 size plane.
I just thought that this was an interesting comparison for anybody who wants to consider different aspects of engine performance.
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload

Robbie- for a .15 size plane, the Magnum (aka ASP) BB .15 is a VG choice, and cheap by comaparison to OS. Good runner out of the box, and much more power than the OS FP. Not too many strong .15's around these days, few compare to the ST G15 that started it all as a production engine with laminar flow (Schnuerle-type) porting and a flat-topped piston. There's still lot of the out-of-production Fox .19's around, too. A big power boost to any model that was designed for a PB .15, and little or no weight penalty. Not designed for it, but like the ST G15 the porting works to benefit a lot from a 2.5 cc pipe if you really want them to scream.
Abel
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload

Polytechforum.com is a website by engineers for engineers. It is not affiliated with any of manufacturers or vendors discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.