LEGO glue or sealant

I have a large LEGO project for school that I am hoping someone can help with. The project involves building a large LEGO sculpture
requiring assembly with "glue" as it has to be on semi-permanent public display and will be manhandled by kids. After 6 months of display, we would like to recover the 50,000 LEGO pieces, so I am seeking a glue that has the following requirements:
- Glue, adhesive, sealant or finish that holds bricks together solid. - does not eat ABS plastic (aka LEGO) - clear and transparent so it does not effect aesthetics, should dry to the same gloss of the original bricks - water soluble (pieces can be soaked in hot water, possibly requiring an agent also that is safe and environ friendly but ideally just water) that completely recovers the bricks and does effect the original finish. - a non-instant 'open' dry time (say, 12-24 hours) to allow for correction of mistakes - Sprayable since idealy it would hold on the outside so I don't have to reassemble glued -or- easy to apply (a glue stick or multiple-use tube or dispenser) and work with (does not bond to fingers, easy clean-up). - relatively inexpensive (not Elmer's but not industrially expensive) - few fumes during use and none after drying
Does such a glue exist?
I have experimented with several glues and am currently using watered-down Elmer's Washable glue sprayed in a light coating. It has many of the above characteristics but the finish is slightly dull and it's so watery that I cannot spray to an even coat (it drips and then pools at the edges giving a uneven, bumpy look). Thank you for your help!
snogards
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload

An interesting problem. While the group choice (rec.toys.lego) reflects your application, I can't help but wonder if there might be a more fruitful location to ask this question.

The usual answer to the first requirement is in direct conflict with the second. Oatey brand plumbing adhesive, sold to glue bits of PVC pipe together, bonds many other plastics very well. I keep a jar around for repairing kids toys. I don't let the kids play with them for a day or so after gluing, as the fumes are nasty. It works by melting the plastic together, which is a bit of an overlap with "eat[ing] ABS".

Let's look at the requirements: clear, glossy, water soluble, slow dry, cheap, low fumes. All of those could be met by simple syrup (ie sugar and water or corn syrup and water). That wouldn't be a strong glue, and long term it would probably collect dust on exposed areas, but it might do the trick for you.
I don't quite understand what you are asking for in the bullet point begining "sprayable...". Are you asking for something to coat the outside of the bricks to hold them together post assembly? That's not really a job for glue...
Elijah ------ simple syrup is sprayable, but might clog a sprayer
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload
Eli the Bearded wrote:

Thank you for the response.
After MUCH experimentation (I've tried spraying and reg. glueing Elmer's Washable Glue AND Gel, Elmer's Glue All, and Aleene's Tacky Glue) I've basically come to the conclusion that it's not possible to glue the outside. Yes, I was hoping to find a clear coating that would both hold the model and save time reassembling.
These glue's work well (the best is Aleene's Tacky) and result in a nice coating if brushed on and a 'medium' hold. A medium hold being that a child cannot pull them apart, but an adult can, it takes some force. The result is a clear coating (no cloudiness) that comes off easily when soaked in a bath tub of warm water. It's almost completely smooth and not noticable with the same gloss as the original bricks, when brushed properly.
An interesting note is that applying the glue on the outside actually results in these glues working into the seams between the bricks somewhat. It's not a perfect seal
When it comes to spraying these glues however they need to be watered down so much (like a milk consistancy) that the result is a runny mess on the non-pourous, slick bricks. The glue just runs off and pools at the corners. When it dries it's uneven and bumpy. So much for the 'dream' of spraying something on this. I must have been crazy to think that will work.
At this point, I think it is unavoidable to glue each brick in place to maintain the original finish... adding alot more work to the projects. That said, I am experimenting with Elmer's Washable Glue versus Aleene's Tacky Glue, glueing a test model together and waiting an entire week (despite the instructions, the actual full cure time for these is a week as with most PVA glue, because of the semi-seal the bricks make and the air pocket inside it takes much longer for these to dry).
I will then do some strength tests. I think the result will be a strong-to-medium hold (stronger than just sprayed) that can be broken by 'adult' hands if needed at the week points. The model is so large it will not fit in a bathtub without breaking into chunks.
The final test will be then to soak the brick chunks in a tub to see if water can get into the seams such that it will fall-apart and the glue will desolve completely, recovering the bricks easily.
Note that Elmer's Washable has GREAT reversabilty but has a POOR hold on plastics. Aleene's is GOOD solubility but has GOOD hold.
I hope I'm not rambling and some day this post'll help someone. I'll follow-up with the best option I find.
Thanks!
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload
replying to snogards99, Christopher Witmer wrote: Thanks for the write up. Exactly what I wanted to know. My son has a Lego set he wants to us as more of a toy and I want to help him get there. Thanks again!
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload
replying to snogards99, Christopher Witmer wrote: Thanks for the write up. Exactly what I wanted to know. My son has a Lego set he wants to us as more of a toy and I want to help him get there. Thanks again!
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
<%-name%>
Add image file
Upload

Polytechforum.com is a website by engineers for engineers. It is not affiliated with any of manufacturers or vendors discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.