1. Home
  2. ⚙ Mechanical Engineering
  3. Maximising magnet holding power of two adjacent knife racks

Maximising magnet holding power of two adjacent knife racks

I have a magnetic knife rack which is mounted inside a cupboard door.

The knives are not as securely held as I would like. What is the best distance and orientation for a second magnetic rack placed parallel to the first one in order to help hold the same set of knives as firmly as possible? I can't tell by hand.

-----

The picture above shows two long magnets on a knife rack and each is sandwiched between two strips of metal. I *GUESS* one long thin surface of a metal strip is N and the other is S. (Is this correct?)

Each rack has two long magnets about an inch apart and maybe they are aligned in a particular way such as "N+S N+S" (going from one side of the knife rack to the other). Or could it be "N+S S+N"?

-----

Based on maximising the magnetic holding power of a knife placers across both racks:

(1) How close to the first rack should the second rack be placed?

(2) Does it matter which type of magnetic pole on one rack is nearest a particular magnetic pole on the other rack? Or is the distance of the two racks (from question 1 above) too great for the magnetism of one to influence the other even when a knife is places across all the metal strips?

Thank you for any info. Chrish

[X-posted: physics, mech eng, DIY]
Reply to
Chrish
Loading thread data ...

I trust you issue the necessary PPE to the cook?

Reply to
Graham.

Get a single knife rack with enough holding power ?

The one I used to have had a very powerful grip (was not cheap £20 odd), so much so after a year or two the two magnetic strips started pulling out when you removed a knife (with all the other knives attached) and after gluing the magnets back in starting ripping the plugs out the wall.

Was replaced with knife holder in a drawer as we suffered from dirt and other kitchen "splatters" accumularing on the knives as there were out in the open.

Reply to
Ian_m

Those little plastic plugs for holding screws into=20 drywall are very poor at resisting forces perpendicular the the wall -- they loosen and will pull out if subjected to repeated tugs. The manufacturers of the plugs don't recommend them for such use, and I don't know=20 why other manufacturers (such as your knife rack supplier) include them with their products. I suppose it's because they're incredibly cheap. Much better to use something=20 like an expansion or toggle bolt fastener.

Why does this form in my mind's eye the image of a medieval kitchen with vats, open fires, and various wildlife being messily slaughtered on a rough wooden bench? :-)

Reply to
Greg Neill

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.