That was one of the big deciding factors for me with the PM1440ELB. A large thru spindle bore. At thee time it was marginally cheaper than the simialr size Grizzly, and had a through spindle bore.
Same with the
These is an denigrating seeming attitude I see sometimes in machining groups. "I don't NEED that," or "I never needed that." Sometimes its just an observation, but most times it seems like either a little bit sour grapes or a put down of somebody who, "Does need that."
Story time. One time I showed a picture of a screw up I made with a round over bit. Worse it was a $100 carbide round over bit. I thought it was amusing. Nothing more. A couple of the manual machinists int he group were quick to quip, "I don't need CNC to cut round overs." The fact is neither do I. I cut my first round overs on an RF30. I didn't respond defensively that I could do it manually too.
Instead I posted a short video of making a dozen t-nuts start to finish on the KMB1 in the time it might take them to make one or two and said, "Yep. You can makes these manually too."
I can do a lot with a little, but that doesn't mean I want to. It doesn't mean I want to. I would much rather do it better and/or faster so I can move on to the next project or go fishing.
Really the whole point though of this video series is to help people do a lot with a little. Most of it will be aimed at beginners or even total non-machinists. I hope anybody who isn't a master might learn something even if they only watch it so they can make themselves feel better by finding things I do to find fault with.
I found the same thing in motorcycles. People who believe and spout off, "If it ain't a Harley it ain't a motorcycle." "People who sneer down their nose at Harley riders as "Slobs humping their rolling speed bumps," and the poor guy who bought his first motorcycle that isn't as fast as squid mobile or as comfortable as a pie to pie rider's bike. I've owned a bunch of motorcycles over the years and more than a couple Harley's, and honestly they have all had things that were good about them. I'd ride any one of them again today if I still had them.
Well, I haven't owned as many mills as motorcycles. Not by a factor of maybe three, but right now there are 9 milling machines in my shop. My "home" shop that was never intended to be a machine shop at all when I put up the building. Every single one of them has some value. I like to think about what I CAN do with them and why I keep them rather than how some other machine in the shop is better or how I don't need the features on one because I can hack it out on one of the smaller less featured machines.
Better or easier doesn't mean what you have is bad. Its just better or easier. I can drill holes in concrete, brick, or rock with a 3lb hammer and a star drill. If I have the time to spend I don't "need" a 1" rotary spline drive rotary hammer to do the job. Just like if the bigger contractor has a core drill it doesn't mean my rotary hammer is bad. It just means he can do the job easier, and maybe faster.
You are right though. A round column mill does have a huge deficiency. There are work arounds, and if that is what they have that's what they have to use.
By the way, Thank you. I fully intend to credit you, and Jim and maybe a couple others atleast in the introductory video as inspiration and for helping me clarify my own motivations and goals for doing this. Almost everybody in this conversation except one has been very helpful in that regard.