I think you are giving up too soon on the stick. I suggested 6013, you insist on working with 7018 Your weld looked fine with the 7018, the sticking problem is endemic with 7018
Stick vs Mig: If you can consistently start a sick rod, your project might go 10% faster with a MIG. Cleanup is also faster on the MIG. Leaving a cold bead on one side of the weld happens with both Mig and stick, it's just more obvious on the stick weld.
If you want an excuse to go get a new tool, have at it! (Insert Tim Allen grunt here) If you want to get the job done in minimal amount of time, then not plan to do any other welding for a while, spend the time working on the stick welder. If you spent 2 full hours over a couple of days running 6013 rod downhand on some scrap plate, you will be doing great. You would spend more time than that just loading up and unpacking the new MIG, not to mention the $600 to $1200 for the new 220 volt MIG.
wander over to sci.engr.jo>