UK rental - okay with auto?!

Jan 01, 2026 Last reply: 5 months ago 22 Replies

Knowing how to shift can help with hauling heavy loads and heavy trailering even when driving a vehicle with an automatic.

I think BIG trucks still mostly have manual transmissions, (I could be wrong) but I'm thinking when running an automatic in a 3/4 or 1 ton pickup running near capacity on mountain roads. On the flat and level not so much, but climbing in and out of Salt River Canyon hauling a full size 3/4 ton pickup with a full size 3/4 ton pickup I was reminded that knowing how to shift, manage rpm, and use brakes without burning them up was invaluable and the truck I was using only had a 6 speed. Even sometimes climbing over telegraph pass I like to keep an eye on everything and have been known to shift manually instead of trusting the automatic to stay in the right gear for engine braking or descent assist depending on the make.

formatting link
My 2000 CRV has an AT with an effective engine braking hill descent mode. It has many of the good features of the Land Rover Freelander it's a near copy of, from a failed joint venture. Fortunately the mechanicals and electricals are Honda, boringly reliable for 20 years or 200,000++ miles. Then the plastic and rubber need replacing, which hasn't been too difficult. Stylists replaced engineers for the later models and made them more normal looking and less practical.

formatting link

formatting link
appears to me that an automated manual has spur gears driving to and from a countershaft like a manual, and computer control of clutch engagement and gear pair selection. This contrasts with an AT which has a torque converter input and planetary gearset as explained here:
formatting link
I still see trucks pull away from green lights in separate distinct steps, as if the driver is rowing the gearshift and double-clutching. Driving Army trucks was sort of like that.
formatting link
"Tire+wheel weighs around 200 lbs." It's a split rim and I learned to change tires. A friend and I broke one of the 1" wheel studs because the L for left-handed thread was filled with paint. The mechanic was more impressed that we could than angry that we did.

I was assigned it because it had a safe welded to the floor in the back to lock up classified material. If at all possible I drove my VW instead, as an uninteresting Bug allowed me to stay overnight in usually delightful village inns where foreigners were rare.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required