I'm upgrading my home made rotary convertor to be able to power a
1.5-2 HP loaded motor. How much bigger than the load motor does the pilot have to be? Will a
2HP pilot be OK or should I go for 2.5 or 3 HP. It's not starting any high torque loads so I don't have to go for the pilot motor that will suit all applications and I'd rather keep the pilot as small as possible.
Thanks
Charles
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
P
pentagrid
With no high starting torque loads 2 Hp will be fine. Jim
J
John Stevenson
Pppppssssstttttt, Wanna buy a motor ????????
-- Regards,
John Stevenson Nottingham, England.
P
Prepair Ltd
Ere! get in the bl**ding queue!! :-))
Peter
-- Peter A Forbes Prepair Ltd, Luton, UK snipped-for-privacy@easynet.co.uk
formatting link
J
Jonathan Barnes
My 7.5 kW pilot motor works fine with my 7.5 kW lath motor, but to help thing along I wired in an extra capacitor bank with the lath motor, as this saves having to re set the converter.
C
Charles Ping
Luckily since this is a 415volt application I think that I have a suitable motor for a change.
Sorry if the cynical traders will have to go without this Christmas.
Charles
J
John Stevenson
Humbug.
-- Regards,
John Stevenson Nottingham, England.
P
Peter A Forbes
Shame on you, Charles, getting our hopes up like that! :-))
Peter
S
Steve Randall
I would have thought (not that I can claim much experiance of this) that the pilot motor could have been the same size or possibly slightly smaller than the load motor.
Ater all power from at least one of the 3 phases would come direct from the mains (i.e only 2/3 of the power will go through the pilot) - and conversion efficencies of commercial units seem to be well above
90%.
Steve
C
Charles Ping
That does lead me ask what the fundemental differences are between commercial static and commercial rotary pahse convertors. The price premium of the rotary seems one hell of a hike for a new motor alone when most of us are very happy with second hand motors in most situations. Should people just buy a static convertor and bolt on a no load pilot?
Charles
J
John Stevenson
I was under the impression that's all they were. Perhaps Jim can chime in here and give us a valid opinion on the differences.?
-- Regards,
John Stevenson Nottingham, England.
P
pentagrid
This is correct and I would take it a stage further.
Try the static converter only solution first to see if you have any problems. If you're short of starting torque or if you need to switch in different load motor combinations then add a pilot to dilute the load variation seen by the static converter.
This comment applies to reputable UK or home brew static converters which include both starting AND run capacitors.
In American practice the term "static converter" is also used to describe buzz boxes which only contain starting capacitors. With these boxes, unless the load motor is substantially derated, a pilot motor is essential.
The static converter only solution will always be short of starting torque but load motor maximum power output is very unlikely to be a problem.
Jim
C
Charles Ping
Thanks Jim. Definitive as ever.
Charles
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.