The team that I normally mentor decided to take a pass this year.
Left me with the opportunity to wander around the Toronto competition, hands hanging, and chat with some of the people.
The first thing I noticed was that there were fewer teams. Last year it was packed. They had to run two competition arenas. So when the competition was going on in one arena, the other one was being set up.
This year, one arena and lots of empty space in the pits.
So I got to wondering why there were fewer teams. And what bothers me about the competition?
Here's my list of irritants/suggestions
- Level the playing field.
I don't know about you, but I DO NOT like to have to compete with the likes of General Motors and other large corporations with vast engineering resources.
And whatever happened to the idea that the student team should do most of the design and build? It's obvious that in many cases the robots were done by the professionals "on staff".
And the students just went along for the ride!
- Drop the cost.
Almost everyone I speak to says that it's too expensive. Even if you spread it around on a cost per student basis, it still comes out as a big number.
There are many ways to improve this equation. One of them is to allow for a wider range of parts and the use of some that were supplied in previous years.
- Try something different.
Maybe it's because I've been down to the Hershey Center for so many years, but I did get a certain "same old, same old" feeling.
The formula seems to be... Wheeled robot moves object to goal. Bonus points if you can do something special at the end. Throw in fifteen seconds of autonomous so people can't say it's just radio control.
Somehow I feel that the boys at NASA can come up with something a little more creative.
- Ease the design/build time pressure.
Sure it can be done. It happens every year. Six weeks from start to finish. Easier if you have professional help. (See item 1.)
But I would like to meet ONE person on an active build team who wouldn't like more time.
And notwithstanding suggestions to the contrary, six weeks of intense work does interfere with studies, social life, vacations...
- You only get one shot.
Unless you can afford to go to several competitions, if your design isn't quite right or it takes more than an hour or two to fix a problem you're cooked.
All that time and effort just went down the drain.
Better luck next year.
- What about the little guy?
Not everyone wants to be on a team and do the "rah, rah! group think" thing!
What about individual competition? Smaller robots? Different classes? One girl one bot?
- Turn the volume down.
OK. Maybe I'm just too old. But has anyone actually checked the decibel level at these events? I'm betting it's well over 100. (hearing damage territory)
DOC
Have robots. Will travel. http//