2004 Wall thickness check

I am considering loading 2004 just for wall thickness check (for plastic
parts) .
Can anyone that is using it already say if it is worth it?
Reply to
Loading thread data ...
I just tried it the other day - I design a fair few plastic injection moulded components ( and then pass on the problems to the toolmakers :-))
I have to say it does not tell you anything about the part you should not already know if you have been designing correctly. The colour shading and interface left me confused and I gave up.
However I suppose it can be usefull if you want to check other peoples work and you are not confident in their ability.
I find the new 'section' viewer in sw2004 far more useful for looking at wall thicknesses and their transitions around a component. There will be parts of a component you want to look at closely and this tool seems to be more useful.
The thickness detector is a bit like the 'undercut' detector. If you design in an undercut unintentionally - you have rushed the job or don't understand geometry. But then we all have to rush jobs and perhaps SW are only trying to be helpful!! I just wish they would be helpfull elsewhere. I get round this with a note on my control drawings to tool makers saying that any undercuts are unintentional and if they find any they should get back to me immediately plus they will get a ticket in my Xmas raffle ;-). Perhaps I ought to offer a tee - shirt.
Sum up - there are better reasons for using 2004 than the thickness detector. I just can't thick of many at the moment.
- I have thought for a moment - Use of multiple configuarions of sub assembly in a main assembly is now possible - no need for Mike Wilson's very inventive work arounds. But I stand to be corrected on this as I only have re-visted this issue for a few hours on sw2004.
Jonathan Stedman
Reply to

Site Timeline

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.