add some elliptical guides to the corners of your profile?
- posted
20 years ago
add some elliptical guides to the corners of your profile?
Is this close to what you need?
Mike,
Thank you for your help and quick response. Unfortunately I'm still running
2001+ and couldn't open your post.
Mike,
Oring grooves are always square. Try it with a rectangle
Regards
Mark
Cubs,
I emailed you an example of what I think you want in 2001+. Real simple, no sweeps or surface cuts.
Regards
Mark
here's the trick the groove
.090 long. The long side of
bottom and top of the
and the top of the groove
an angle around the
one o-ring, rotating the
groove. I created an angled
Now that I think of it, how the hell are you gonna cut that groove ????? It's impossible !
You'll have to make it out of three pieces, a central cylinder, and two slash cut rings. You'll also have to make a fixture to press, or pin, the three pieces together.
Regards
Mark
Well,
My email got bounced back
If you want the model, email me privately with a good return address
(remove the obvious from my address to reach me)
Mark
here's the trick the groove
.090 long. The long side of
bottom and top of the
and the top of the groove
an angle around the
one o-ring, rotating the
groove. I created an angled
Regards Darryl
You'll have to make it out of three pieces, a central cylinder, and two slash cut rings. You'll also have to make a fixture to press, or pin, the three pieces together.
Regards
Mark
I see! OK, here's another try in 2001Plus...
Mike,
That one's allot more machinable than what I came up with. The walls are normal to the bottom of the groove. There is something wierd going on though, (at first glance). It looks like the bottom doesn't have a constant width.
Regards
Mark
Mike,
OK... mine doesn't have an equa width bottom either, it's just harder to see. So, it looks like this really is challenging. I "KNOW" that if I write a CNC program for my fourth axis, using axis substitution (where the "Y" is swapped for the 'A") I can machine it. If the cutter has a dead flat bottom, and if I follow the center line of the groove with the axis of the cutter right on center with the cylinder.
I've been trying for about an hour to duplicate this in SW, no luck. Think sweeping a cylinder, not a 2D profile along the curve. The axis of the swept cylinder is allways pointed right at the center of the cylinder being cut. Don't think the tools are in there to do this.
Regards
Mark
That's funny, It's definitely not as easy as I first thought. Maybe third times a charm?
Does anyone else have a solution they would like to share? I would be interested in seeing it!
Mike Wilson
yes I did a hybrid solution-used a circular profile to cut sweep around an elliptical path to define the correct edge profile at the cyl surface-this is not actually a straight line in profile-and then used the 2 outside surfaces to thicken into 2 body rings, made into a whole with a merging cylinder-hid the original body. hope you followed that folks
Mike,
I think this approach looks pretty close to the angled grrove.....much better than mine.
Thanks
Mike,
Very good ! I was working on something similar when I ran out of gas last night.
The cross section perpendicular to the groove at the center is about .086, but it's real close.
This will go into the tips and tricks folder on our server
Regards
Mark
Thanks Matt! I think I like your method the best. I knew there was a way to do it with a sweep.
Regards, Mike
"Mike J. Wilson" wrote in news:4Nudne51x_ snipped-for-privacy@giganews.com:
Mike:
I was going to try to make a point about it being better to do it using solid features rather than surface features ("that old chestnut" to quote Dr. Evil), but I found that mine (solids) rebuilt in about 2 seconds and the second one you did (surfaces) rebuilt in 0.8. Your first one rebuilt in 3.4. I'm curious as to why the thickened part rebuilds so much faster than the other methods. Any ideas?
matt
"Corey Scheich" wrote in news:bhr3n4$28tkb$ snipped-for-privacy@ID-200385.news.uni-berlin.de:
Yeah, you're right, I made that mistake the first try. In the model I posted, I used a dummy point to make the pierce to the GC and used a dimension for the width.
matt
snipped-for-privacy@chi.com wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com:
I would except that I don't have 2001+ on my machine anymore. Would a parasolid (no features) be of any use?
Matt
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.