It has been very interesting to read several recent threads about "best" HO "systems", Marklin, Hornby, etc. If we set size and time aside, I'd be curious how others rate model train "systems". Step one is to define what is a model train system. I suggest it is a complete, compatible product line from a single manufacturer that should include:
o locomotives o rolling stock o track o power supplies and power distribution o signals o on-line RR-related structures and industrial accessories o off-line structures and scenery
I'd give my first place vote to Lionel in the 1930's, as in addition to all the essentials, they offered the 439 and 440 power control panels and the various scenic parks and homes. I think Lionel takes a second to American Flyer, Hornby and Marklin on the prototype fidelity of their locos and cars. I think Marklin ranks number one for the elegance of their plug connected switch control, power routing and signal systems. I'd give points to Hornby in the 90's for a good line of non-RR structures. Comments? Geezer