Well, it isn't as though this issue isn't quantifiable. Of course, drawing a conclusion requires that we make subjective decisions about cost, clean-up, residue, etc. So it is possible that someone may favor synthetic oils over castor oils. It really depends upon their priorities.
There was a time when I had had it with the tedious clean ups and the varnish that castor oil produced. I burned nothing but synthetic oil type fuels for several years of very active flying.
As long as I stayed with using high quality engines I had no problems. If I ventured away from OS, Enya, Webra, YS or Rossi I paid the price. At the time I didn't have much time for venturing, so Morgan's Cool Power served me well.
Ed Cregger