Dear Blacksmithing newsgroup subscribers,
I'm a newbie at blacksmithing, and I'm currently trying to acquire an anvil for myself. I would appreciate your input in helping me choose one.
I am considering purchasing a Peter Wright for 800 dollars. It is a 202 pound anvil in rather good condition. You can see it here,
The other alternative I am considering, is buying a new JHM 260 pound "competitor" anvil for around the same price as the PW mentioned above. Perhaps I should forget about the PW and just go with the JHM, since it is 60 pounds heavier, and after all, I'm getting "more anvil for my buck". The JHM, though, seems to be categorized mainly as a farrier anvil, and that seems evident by the fact that the area from the waist to the heel of the anvil is concave in shape.
However, the shape under the heel of your typical London pattern anvil is not concave, it is straight. This makes me think that the JHM has less structural support under its heel than a regular london pattern anvil like the Peter Wright, and so may not be able to take the blow of a sledge hammer as well as the typical London pattern. Is there any merit in this theory of mine? Maybe it's irrelevant, since one would not be hammering so heavily in the heel area of an anvil, anyway?
On the other hand, the face and body of the JHM is hardened, modern steel, and will probably produce a better hammer rebound than the old PW? Then again, the JHM is cast, and might be structurally inferior to the PW's wrought iron construction? There's a lot of variables I'm trying to weigh.
Another anvil I was considering buying, was the Peddinghaus forged anvil, but I learned that those are no longer in production. I have been looking around to buy one second-hand, but can't find one. I've recently sent off my application and payment to join the California Blacksmithing Association. What do you all think my chances are of finding a Peddinghaus or Peter Wright in the classified ad section of the CBA's magazine, "The California Blacksmith"? People who have Peddinghas anvils are probably not in a hurry to sell them, right?
Maybe at the end of the day my best option is to go with the Peter Wright, even if it is overpriced? I'm trying to get the best overall quality and performance out of an anvil. What do you all think? Raffi Aidiniantz