Thanks guys. I'll tell you my project and maybe you can give me some ideas.
We have a steam superheater and we are finally joining the 21st century and putting in on our DCS. We have a stack tip temperature that we want to have an analog value coming into the DCS, but on a high temperature we want to shut down the heater. A manual furnace shutdown or a high stack temperature shutdown falls into the ESD catagory and will be controlled by our Triconex ESD PLC. So now I have one spot to measure temperature and want to send an analog value to the DCS (Bailey Infi 90) and will do some alarming in there, and then send a digital to the Triconex to shut the furnace down.
United Electric makes a 'One Series' type switch which is acutally a digital switch. The setpoint is programmed into it, and you can also buy them with a 4-20 mA output as well. They claim they're approved for Safety Systems use. I've never used one, buy have been curious to try one for a while. I'm not sure of how accurate and repeatable they are. I can't see them being as good as a Rosemount. I've seen it where the analog value has been brought into the DCS, gone through a Hi/Lo block and then a digital out goes to a PLC but to me that defeats the whole purpose of an SIS.
Anyway, that's why I'm asking about Tx's and switches. Anymore thoughts would be cool. Thanks
Curtis