Broken SDS drill bit

Jul 12, 2014 8 Replies

Can anybody (Ed ... ?) see anything in the linked photo that might say something about the break? I left the photo big (2000 x 1200) to keep details.



It's the shank of an SDS max drill bit. Carbide tipped, so I thought the shank would be mild. Yet, to me, the break looks like that of hard steel.



Does the varying color mean anything?



formatting link



Thanks, Bob


Bob Engelhardt fired this volley in news: snipped-for-privacy@news1.newsguy.com:

First of all, the shank didn't break, the web did.

Second, it's been broken for a long time, and just finally failed.

Lloyd

Can anybody (Ed ... ?) see anything in the linked photo that might say something about the break? I left the photo big (2000 x 1200) to keep details.

It's the shank of an SDS max drill bit. Carbide tipped, so I thought the shank would be mild. Yet, to me, the break looks like that of hard steel.

Does the varying color mean anything?

formatting link

Thanks, Bob

=================================================

That's interesting. Fracture mechanics is something I haven't dealt with in

20 years, and I never could say anything conclusive about fractures, but it looks like some kind of shear fracture. In general, the darker area in one of these fractures indicates fatigue, and the brighter areas indicate brittle fracture.

It doesn't mean the metal was brittle. If it really was fatigue that started it, the rest just shows where the remaining metal was overloaded.

I doubt if the shank is anything less than a good tool steel. Mild steel wouldn't take the pounding. Beyond that, I don't know.

OK. I was thinking of "shank" as everything behind the tip. Not anymore.

Meaning that there was a defect in it?

Thanks, Bob

Thanks, that helps. Bob

Bob Engelhardt fired this volley in news: snipped-for-privacy@news1.newsguy.com:

Perhaps, or perhaps it had been flexed or twisted to the point of cracking in some prior use. But it wasn't during _this_ use.

Lloyd

Wait, that wasn't the web you meant? Sorry!

Cute, but no Brownie Points. And speaking of points, have you downloaded your Algore Smog credits yet?

formatting link
They're Deeeeeeeeeeecarboniferous!

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required