I'm considering getting a gear caliper and was hoping to get feedback
on it's usefulness. Are these worth it or can I accurately measure
gears without one?
And if I get one, are there any features, materials, measuring scales
I should be looking for?
Thanks a lot.
Darren Harris
Staten Island, New York.
I picked up a starret one of these, I think on ebay - but I watched for a
long time before one went cheaply enough to just have around. Now, truth be
told, I haven't needed to use it yet...
It depends on what you want to measure.
The only thing that they are good for is measuring the thickness
of the tooth at the pitch diameter.
What it does is it allows you to set a stop precisely to control
how deep the jaws go prior to measuring the width -- so you do it at the
pitch diameter.
But to do this, you need to know what the pitch of the gear is
to start with. I guess that you could try different depth settings and
keep trying until you get a tooth thickness which matches the depth for
a known pitch diameter.
The only ones which I know are available in two different sizes,
and unless you are making gers for machines which you can't move by hand
(and likely can't even move the gear by hand), you want the smaller size.
And if you are getting them from eBay, you almost certainly will
wind up with an inch set, not a metric one, though Starrett makes both
styles.
The sizes in inch units which Starrett offers are for 20-2 DP
and 10-1 DP
And the metric ones are for 1-1/4 - 12 Module and 2-1/2 - 25
Module.
You want the smaller one (larger DP or smaller module), and IIRC
you found your lathe's gears were 1 module, so they are too fine for
even the smaller of the two metric ones.
The new prices back in January 1998 ranged from $759.00 to
$944.00 depending on size and whether supplied with case.
It appears to not be listed at all in the current on-line
Starrett catalog. You should watch eBay for a copy of their Catalog
#29s -- which has advice on how to use the gear tooth calipers.
Good Luck,
DoN.
+1
They'll tell you what circular tooth thickness at the depth you set it
for.
... Presumably (properly) at the Pitch Diameter...
You'll get more use, for less money (and less monkeying around) with
some standard tenths reading mics, some proper wires, and a disc mic.
Arguably, you could use a caliper in lieu of the disc mic.
... and if you do get a disc mic, get a non-rotating spindle one to
keep your life easier...
I cut a LOT of gears, and inspect almost as many while making them...
I inspect most by hand, and some at intervals on a gear inspection
machine.
For my money I'd buy a disk anvil micrometer as others have advised
here, and become familiar with chordal gear measurements as amply
described in Machinerys Handbook.
Methinks this method of gear measurement beats the others "hands
down".
Wolfgang
[ ... ]
Not of that specific piece of information. The question is
mostly whether you truly need that specific piece of information.
Hmm ... the price is attractive, and it is in metric units,
which matches your needs for making gears for the lathe.
Certainly not a plain micrometer -- unless you mill off the
teeth adjacent to the one which you are trying to measure. :-)
And the disc micrometer, while it can reach in there, has
nothing to set how deep you are measuring.
Do you have a copy of _Machinery's Handbook_ yet?
If so -- look up "gear -- tooth caliper, vernier" in the index,
and turn to the first page listed (1938 in the 25th edition, elsewhere
in other editions).
Look at the drawing, showing the gear tooth vernier in use.
Look in particular at the fact that it is measuring at the "pitch
circle" of the gear, which is a point along the curved face of the gear.
The end of the vertical scale of the gear tooth vernier rests on the top
of the tooth, and limits how far down the measuring jaws go. Without
that, there is no way to be sure that you are measuring at the proper
point on the tooth. Too high, and you get a narrower tooth reading than
you should have -- too low, and you get a wider reading. So -- *if*
(and only if) you need the correct reading of this datum, you need the
gear tooth vernier. Based on a quick reading of this section, the gear
tooth vernier and its measurement is used mostly when cutting a gear
with a hobbing machine -- not something you will have available (nor
could you get one up to your apartment if you had one -- they are big
and *heavy*. You use it for adjusting the hobber to produce the needed
clearance on large gear teeth by setting the hobber just a little deeper
than normal.
So -- if you *want* a gear tooth vernier just to have one (as I
did), then go for this. The price is a lot better than you are likely
to find on a used Starrett or B&S one.
However, you don't really *need* it.
Enjoy,
DoN.
Sure you can. That's one of the beautiful things about gears -
EVERYTHING is related.
With a relatively few parameters, you can get to everything else you
need or want.
That's why one uses Van Keuren wires to get in there. (:>)
But you can use it to measure the span across the
tangencies, and back track that to get other information.
Van Keuren wires* and mic will tell you what you need, here.
Preferably a tenths mic.
* - I have, in a pinch, used gauge pins some times...
I hob at work, and at home, and have never had necessity
for one yet, but instead rely on wires and other measurements.
Besides, if you need to thin (or thicken) the Circular Tooth Thickness
while
hobbing a gear, it is not a 1:1 relation anyway, so you still need to
do the math.
In other words, if you need to alter the tooth thickness .001", you do
not adjust the hob's cutting depth by .001"
There's a relationship...
For instance, for a 40 Tooth gear of 20 degree Pressure Angle -
To alter the Circular Tooth Thickness by .001", you would change the
hob's cutting depth by .0014"
For a 40 Tooth gear of 14.5 degree Pressure Angle, it would be .
00155".
... certainly haven't yet... (:>)
They certainly *are* cool looking though, and I'd be forced to buy
one if I tripped across one in person, for relatively little money!
But not limited to the tools which he listed.
There is where you are going beyond his listed tools. :-)
I presume that a specific diameter of pin is needed for at least
each pitch diameter -- and if the tooth has been thinned, you will need
a slightly larger wire.
O.K. With more math, of course.
Again -- how critical is the diameter of the pins? Can you
adjust for wrong diameter pins by cranking through some math -- as you
can for thread pitch three-wire measurement?
O.K. You have the wires. How much would a set of appropriate
wires cost him, compared to that gear tooth vernier? (And, of course,
they could be used for other measurements, which the G.T. vernier could
not.
Of course -- so for the math challenged, the gear tooth vernier
gives the quick and dirty way of verifying that the extra depth will do
it.
Since the hob is providing a pure trapezoidal shape (and
depending on the multiple cuts to generate the needed involute shape),
yes. If using a set of involute gear tooth mills, however, the
calculations are likely to be a bit more complex.
Exactly! I think that I got mine (in a nice plush-lined leather
covered fitted box) for something about the range of the import one
which he is looking at. This was after watching many go for much more
on eBay -- I just lucked into mine at the right time, I think.
Enjoy,
DoN.
To get the proper size wires, divide 1.728 by Diametral Pitch.
Wires will most often check a fairly large range of Circular Tooth
Thicknesses, too, for a given DP.
As critical as one wants to be, or not... (:>)
Yes, one can calculate for over/under wire sizes.
Wires are relatively cheap.
One could buy individual Gage Pins for about $2.50 USD, each, I
believe...
(more or less, depending on quality and origin...)
No more complex. Just different. (:>)
Machinery's Handbook has all of this in it.
Did I mention that bevel gears are on my project list.(Providing I can
figure out how to cut them without a dividing head). :-)
(But I assume it doesn't change anything, and I can still accurately
measure those type gears without a GTV, correct?).
Thanks.
Darren Harris
Staten Island, New York.
[ ... ]
I have *no* idea. Open your copy of _Machinery's Handbook_ (you
*do* have one by now, don't you?) and read all about gears and gear
tooth cutting. I've never considered making a bevel gear so I haven't
bothered reading about them. I'm not even sure that a Gear Tooth
Vernier would be usable on a bevel gear, because the shape and
dimensions of the tooth vary as you move from the major diameter to the
minor diameter.
And you *will* need at least some form of dividing head, along
with special sets of gear tooth cutters for the Bevel gears. You can't
use the standard involute cutters for straight tooth gears.
Enjoy,
DoN.
==========
If you are going to make or think about making gears I
highly recommend Law's book "Gears and Gear Cutting." It is
one of the workshop series and stresses home made gears
including bevel/miter gears.
see
formatting link
?productId=243&categoryId=-1
-- Unka George (George McDuffee)
..............................
The past is a foreign country;
they do things differently there.
L. P. Hartley (1895-1972), British author.
The Go-Between, Prologue (1953).
I've been told probably 1/2 dozen times that that is the book to get
and I've been trying to get that book along with a few other "Workshop
Practice" titles. (And I see that in the link you posted Amazon is
only selling it for one grand. :-)
This is what I'm waiting for:
formatting link
But apparently there is a shipping problem. (See below)...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------=
-----------------------------------------------------------------
"Dear Darren,
I am very sorry for the delay and not returning your emails untill
now.
The Publishers of Gears and Gear Cutting have just told us that a
shipment is due from Malta on the 4th August 2010. The books have been
stuck in Malta after reprinting waiting for enough other books for
shipping. We will get our shipment a few days after that.
If you can wait we will send your book straight out when it arrives,
if not we will refund you in full.
There is no problem with your other book Workholding in the lathe
except we were hoping to send them together as 1 package.
Sorry once again,
Thank you for your extreme patience so far,"
---------------------------------------------------------------------------=
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I guess that's what I get for ordering from outside of the country.
So I'm still waiting. But as for measuring gears, this auction win I
received is proving to be interesting:
formatting link
So with my Machinery's Handbook(27th Edition), which I've temporarily
misplaced in a room full of "stuff", that should tie me over until I
get the Ivan Law book. :-)
I really want to get into the tool making aspects of machining and was
wondering if making my own cutters would be plausible. (But without a
surface grinder I guess this would be difficult).
And I'm still searching for a mini dividing head. :-)
Thanks everyone.
Darren Harris
Staten Island, New York.
Oh good -- you *do* have _Machinery's Handbook_.
You can make the cutters with a bench grinder a magnifier and
patience. (Something like an optical comparator will help to check a
tool against a scaled-up drawing of what it should be -- but you can
grind by hand and check against a gear of near the same number of teeth
(given DP and PA the same, of course, or metric equivalents).
There are small ones for the Unimat and the Emco-Maier C5 mill
which will handle certain fixed numbers of divisions. IIRC, 32, 36,
40, and 48 divisions -- and subsets of those. But if you need an odd
number of teeth you will have problems for many of those.
Good Luck,
DoN.
Actually, you can. The process is described in Law's book, mentioned
below.
It's a good book to have. One of the nice things is that it is
written
from the perspective of actually *doing* things, and getting things
done.
I'm a bit of a freak about gears, kind of obsessive/compulsive,
having
a love of them, the design process, the manufacturing process, and
tooling.
As such, I think that Dudley's book is a mandatory possession.
Another one you might want to look at is Edgar's which is available on
Gooogle books.
formatting link
There are many others, and others will likely chime in with the old
standards and links to them.
Personally, I seem to gain more from the tooling (hobs and shaper
cutter) design texts,
and have found the technical handbooks and texts from Barber Colman to
have been INVALUABLE.
Ironically enough, after diving in and dedicating so much time and
effort to the subject and the texts
mentioned, I have found (in retrospect) that Machinery's Handbook has
90% of everything you will ever need.
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.