OT Humidity & electronics

Sep 18, 2005 20 Replies
Jump to replies (20)

I like Hewlett Packard calculators. I have two HP32SII's and a 42S, have worn out several others over the years since the HP-35, the first scientific handheld calculator with trig functions and all. I felt lucky as hell to find one of those used at $135, in the early '70s when that was more than a house payment. That's when I retired my trusty Post Versalog slide rule. I also have an HP48G but I've never liked it much. Too damned complicated for everyday use.



One 32SII has been my shop/lab workhorse for over a decade. The buttons are still legible, all but one anyway. Lately some of the buttons got to be intermittent. Got out the "backup" 32SII I spotted (and glommed) in a bookshop years ago after HP had quit making them. There were none to be had here but this bookshop was on a back street in Ghent, Belgium.



Same keyboard problem with it, though it has about no "miles" on it. Oh, darn! Got out the 42S which I'd been hoarding because I



*really* like that calculator. Same thing. Ooooooo nooooooo!

Battery voltages all looked fine. I put new batteries in one anyway. No help.



Then I recalled that one of my fishing sonars got wierd earlier this year after a 1-week fishin' trip where it rained nearly every day. One might think that a boat gadget would be weatherproof, right? Maybe it was when new 6 years ago.



I'd bagged the sonar with a 1-oz desiccant pack for a few days. That fixed it, as expected.



Mmmm (you can see it coming already, right?) I bagged the calculators in a ziplock with a desiccant pack. Three days later, they all work perfectly.



I'm gonna start using the 42S now. It's in brand-new condition but it probably won't be for long, with everyday use in the shop/lab. What the hell, I'm gonna enjoy it while I can still see it.



The 32SII's will be transferred to a screw-top jar with a coupla desiccant paks.


Me to. And I still want my HP 16C back that someone was stolen from me.

It would trade it for a HP 28

Nick

The 32S II problem is the contacts from the keyboard to the circuit board. They've got a fairly standard flexible printed circuit connector held down with foam in them. This gets a little bit of corrosion on it and the connection gets wonky. The real problem is that HP made these calculators really difficult to take apart. If you do try to take one apart there's some melted plastic post type connections under the keyboard metal cover. Of course there's the rub because taking glued on cover off without hurting it is a little tricky. I did mine and got it to function 100% again. But I've never gotten around to doing a proper reglue of the metal cover. I've just got some clips bent from wire holding it down. Not the most elegant but it's doing the job so far.

I got the replacement 33s this last week. Some nice features but who ever did the keyboard layout should be shot. It's also just a little bit larger than the 32S II and does not fit in a shirt pocket as well. I wish I could get another couple of 32S II without paying the ridiculous going price on ebay. That's got to be the best shop calculator ever made.

I still miss my old 31E. It had all the important functions in a uncluttered keyboard.

After looking at a picture of the 42s I bet it's the same as the 32s II on the problem. I agree with the complication. I had it's predecessor the 41CV and never liked it at all.

Wayne Cook Shamrock, TX

formatting link

To me, this is like saying I'd rather drive my car in reverse on the freeway. Does HP still use that RPN logic? What on earth is the reason for it and WHY would anyone like it? ( I know - I'm just troolling)

Karl

I still have, love, and use my 15C, although I admit I also use a TI-83Plus now which is neat because it graphs. Nobody can beat the early HP user interface, though, and that includes the later HP group that made the model 28s. What a POS, it was like having to learn a whole new programming language to use the thing.

Very neat idea about the baggie and desiccant, D> I like Hewlett Packard calculators. I have two HP32SII's and a 42S,

That's just because you've never really tried it long enough to get used to it. Once you've use RPN for a while you quickly realize that it's the best method of inputting data into a calculator out there. I learned it when doing UIL calculator competition. In competition if you didn't us RPN you was working with a handy cap that had to be overcome if you wanted to win. It took more keystrokes, more time studying the problem before entering (so that you made sure you started in the right place), more memory on your part (to remember the exact steps and number of "(" you'd entered), more everything. With RPN you just started entering and used the stack to manipulate the problem as needed during entry.

Wayne Cook Shamrock, TX

formatting link

Present offerings can run in RPN or traditional mode.

RPN is useful because it eliminates parentheses. Once learned, it is much easier to calculate complex expressions (without error) with RPN. You do the innermost calculations (deepest level of parentheses) first, intermediate results go on the stack, and so on.

I've been using RPN for so long I have trouble with a regular calculator. If I don't have an HP handy I let my wife (former beancounter) do the calculating. I don't really "need" RPN anymore, but it's what I'm used to and comfortable with.

The advent of the PC has changed things. I now do complex expressions in MathCAD because I can see the whole expression (and input errors) on the screen -- and it's easy to use repetitively just by changing a variable. It's too bad that MathCAD has gotten so expensive with a surfeit of features. The first versions for $49 that came on one or two floppies did nearly everything I ever want to do with it.

I wish APL (Ted Edwards' favorite) were available for Windows at reasonable price. (I would consider $49.95 as "reasonable") There are times when I'd find that useful for simple programs to just compute a numerical result or set of results, or iteratively search for a solution that meets a set of constraints. MathCAD can do it but iterative programs with conditional branching are cumbersome to write and the programs execute rather slowly. Any interpretive program or "script" --BASIC, VB, MathCAD, etc -- is considerably slower than a program that can be compiled and executed. Speed is less of a problem as 'puters get faster, but "programs" in MathCAD are still a pain to write.

Karl sez: "> To me, this is like saying I'd rather drive my car in reverse on the

My guess is that in the early design days it was not economically feasible to produce chips to support direct algebraic entry. Thus, RPN was developed as a crutch, more or less, to facilitate HP's entry into the calculator market. We were taught by HP (General Bullmoose ? ) to manipulate a "stack" in order to accommodate their klunky entry system. And so, RPN became the de facto standard. Besides, it had great appeal for those that would have us believe "computer math" was beyond the reach of ordinary intelligence. Like, "Hey, if you ain't smart enough to learn to do backwards arithmetic, you got no business with a calculator anyway."

Bob Swinney

For me, I keep a TI graphic type in the shop - because I have a big screen and computing ability there. Something of a high or medium level language actually. Forth ?

Anyway - the HP 28C (In rich leather) with the thermo printer (IR) in the desk. I can shoot the IR beam and print on my HP 990 color printer! wow - the late 80's calculator using a 2003 printer.

I like the 28 - did know it much more when I used it at work - had the 'strip' computer there - boxes of mag strips - sad when that died. The 28 now lasts and lasts on batteries - finally got fresh N size.

Martin Martin Eastburn @ home at Lions' Lair with our computer lionslair at consolidated dot net NRA LOH, NRA Life NRA Second Amendment Task Force Charter Founder

Nick Müller wrote:

I think APL would have taken off a bit more, but he special keyboard...

Ok ya - just have Logitech make a special - Now I'm using a logitech wireless mouse and wireless keyboard on the house computer and I have the (wow) MX 1000 laser in the shop. I think now the keyboard is a mute point - easy to overcome.

Martin Martin Eastburn @ home at Lions' Lair with our computer lionslair at consolidated dot net NRA LOH, NRA Life NRA Second Amendment Task Force Charter Founder

D> >

Nope - 4 bangers were out all over the place doing non-RPG. Engineers used RPG, business types used algebraic. Some were caught between because schools began to program people. I use both myself - time and a place and keeps my mind able in both in case I have to use one somewhere away from home...

Martin Martin Eastburn @ home at Lions' Lair with our computer lionslair at consolidated dot net NRA LOH, NRA Life NRA Second Amendment Task Force Charter Founder

Robert Sw> Karl sez:

According to Robert Swinney :

RPN happens to be how computer languages mannipulate math internal to the programs. It is much more compact, so it allows you to do more with a given amount of hardware -- and if the hardware can be increased, you can add more functions, instead of tying it up handling parens.

I got my first HP (a 45) back when those were new. I've gone through a few of the subsequent ones, finally stopping at the 15C (for scientific calculations), and the 16C (for computer math manipulations). I've got one of each in my belt pouch, and a spare 15C in a Ziploc baggie in the shop, where it can be used without lubricants or coolant soaking into it. (Put it in facing the back of the baggie where there is no printing.)

Before the HP-45, I was using a Cannon printing calculator with algebraic notation (but no trig functions or other fancy stuff).

So -- I vastly prefer the RPN to algebraic calculators.

FWIW, the unix calculator programs bc and dc both use a variant of RPN. And the GUI interface one, "xcalc" has the option to use either algebraic notation or RPN. Guess which I have it set to? (And the keyboard shuffles when you change the notation system to look either like a HP 15C or some TI calculator of the same period.

Enjoy, DoN.

Yep, Martin remember us at Motorola? Engineering had the only computer in the place; definitely RPN. It was HP, of course; it'd take several hours to run a site intermodulation program. The other few calculators around were Bomar Brain 4 bangers. In those days I bought one of the first TI algebraic models that came out. I've owned lots of TI's since then including one with the "gum stick wrapper" programmer. I've tried both RPN and algebraic - I still prefer algebraic.

Bob Swinney

Yep. But the going rate of around $150 for a good one is a bit steep.

Wayne Cook Shamrock, TX

formatting link

I'll bet you meant to write "hygroscopic". It's clear what you mean.

Another poster says it does. I wanted to try a non-invasive fix before I drilled out the heat-staked posts that hold the case together.

I forget where I'd heard about the problem before I broke into mine but it does have a flexible connecter. The proper name escapes me but I'm sure you know what I'm talking about. Clear with traces on it. This is held in sandwich with the display board, and the circuit board by a piece of foam. A little corrosion on the contacts and it gets flaky. Unfortunately a long cry from the old HP which went to great lengths to make them reliable.

As stated before the only real problem is trying to get the keyboard metal template off without hurting it. They glued that thing on very well.

Wayne Cook Shamrock, TX

formatting link

Can't say Bob - what group ? I covered all over Austin and flew into 'AZ' to help out there from time to time.

Must have been in the Memory division ? Product Marketing maybe. I'd bet SRAM - mostly worked with DRAM and Design - some with EEPROM (as long as they lasted) always with test engineering.

I have many fond memories working in the Austin facility. Lot of work and frustration to the max some times.

Yep - had a SR-50 at the time myself an soon in 87 I switched to my HP 28C.

Bomar Brains - Long time since I heard that one.

We had a Cannon 12 digit NIXIE tube readouts 4 banger with memory. I was doing logs on it and had methods for trig calculations when the SR-50 came out - praise the keyboard!

Martin

Martin Eastburn @ home at Lions' Lair with our computer lionslair at consolidated dot net NRA LOH, NRA Life NRA Second Amendment Task Force Charter Founder

Robert Sw> Yep, Martin remember us at Motorola? Engineering had the only computer in

According to Wayne Cook :

Flexible printed circuit board, I believe.

Enjoy, DoN.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required