Report on HF wrench quality

Yeah, I know: "HF" & "quality" do not belong in the same sentence 8-)
And I know that you get what you pay for. Nevertheless, I do own a set
of HF metric combo wrenches. And for several years they have been
satisfactory in very undemanding use. Today I found the limit on one of
them.
I was replacing a tie rod end and trying to loosen it when the wrench
just broke. I was in an awkward position and using a hand on each of 2
wrenches, going opposite ways, so I wasn't leaning on the wrench. Or
using a cheater. Pretty modest demand.
In my shop, I reproduced the situation, more or less, using a torque
wrench and found that I could exert 65 ft-lbs on an 18" torque wrench,
or 43lbs force. 43lbs on the 9" HF wrench is only 32 ft-lbs torque!
The break was on the open end of the wrench, right where the straight
side meets the rounded inner side. A stress riser location, to be sure.
I'm thinking about taking a die grinder and "fairing" that point on
the other wrenches. I wonder if it would be worth it.
Bob
Reply to
Bob Engelhardt
Loading thread data ...

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.