OT: Taps May Not be "Live" at Vets Funerals Anymore

from CNN-

Push-button bugle to play taps at military funerals Thursday, September 4, 2003 Posted: 12:50 PM EDT (1650 GMT)

Real buglers like this one are in short supply.

RELATED Military struggles to provide funeral honors

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Ceremonial Bugle WASHINGTON (AP) -- Chronically short of musicians for military funerals, the Pentagon has approved the use of a push-button bugle that plays taps by itself as the operator holds it to his lips.

Only some 500 buglers are on active duty on any one day, but about

1,800 people with military service die across the country each day and are eligible for honors ceremonies, Air Force Lt. Col. Cynthia Colin, a Pentagon spokeswoman, said Thursday.

So the Defense Department worked with private industry to invent the "ceremonial bugle," which has a small digital recording device inserted into its bell to play the music.

A member of the honor guard at the funeral simply presses a button on the device. A five-second delay gives the guards time to raise the instrument to their lips as if they are going to play it.

The vast majority of families endorsed its use in a six-month test from November to May in Missouri, where 50 prototypes were distributed to military units and others who provide funeral honors, such as veterans groups, the Pentagon said in a statement Wednesday night.

Based on the test, use of the instrument was approved by Principal Deputy Under Secretary Charles S. Abell. A real bugler still will be used when available. Otherwise, the family of the deceased service member will be offered the ceremonial bugle as an alternative to prerecorded taps, often played on a boom box.

Use of the $500 instrument "is intended to enhance the dignity of military funeral honors," the Pentagon said. Also, it plays "an exceptionally high-quality rendition of taps that is virtually indistinguishable from a live bugler," the Pentagon said.

The military has been struggling for years to cope with its shortage of musicians for funerals. Families of honorably discharged veterans are entitled to a two-person uniformed funeral honor guard, the folding and presentation of the U.S. flag and a rendition of taps.

Congress passed a law that took effect in January 2000 and allows a recorded version of taps using audio equipment if a live horn player is not available. Officials say the push-button bugle is a dignified alternative because the visual effect of a guard playing the instrument is better than taps played on a stereo or compact disc player.

Reply to
Craig
Loading thread data ...

Sad. Having attended a few military funerals with real live buglers, I can tell you that a lone bugler off in the distance adds an air of great dignity to the ceremony. Of course, there are a few times when there were *two* buglers, one a second or so behind the other (this is intentional)... and that makes you want to go and hide behind a rock. It's almost physically painful, it's so powerful.

Reply to
Scott Lowther

Amen. My father was a Royal Navy Command Bugler and played for several funerals in his time and he's always said that there are two things a military man/woman requires at their funeral, 1) a bugler to send them on their way, and 2) the flag of their country (ex-RN like having the White Ensign) draped over the coffin (my father firmly believes that if they were good enough to serve under the flag then they are good enough to be buried under it).

Jimi

Reply to
Jimi

I did about 10 funerals after they enacted the law in 2000. Myself and a Regular Army LTC were the only two active soldiers in the this Reserve Component unit (Simulation Center at Ft. Dix).

Seems that when the lawmakers decided to have the USAR/ARNG do these ceremonies, they failed to include a provision to order these soldiers to active duty and give them "drill credit" and pay them for travel expenses.

Therefore, every time a funeral requirement in our area occurred and it was our unit's turn, we were tasked to provide the two-man honor guard. The amount of times our unit had this duty was based on total unit strength (about 175 pers.) and not active soldier strength (a Major and Lieutenant Colonel).

The two of us got pretty good at flag folding and hitting the play button on the boom box (Taps on CD). We usually got a funeral home worker to push the button at the appropriate time.

The only funeral we didn't do was one that occurred during a drill weekend. By the time the two of us left in mid 2001, they changed the rules and brought on four reserve enlisted soldiers full time (ADSW or Active Duty Special Work) just to conduct the two-man honor guard.

It was an honor and a privilege to conduct these ceremonies and the two of us performed them in a professional manner. It was just not the most efficient use of time for two field grade officers.

A couple of the funerals had real live buglers, but these were both from a local VFW (or American Legion?) chapter that the deceased belonged to or had ties with.

A requirement for a third person to be there as a "pretend bugler" would have made all but 3 of the funerals I attended undoable. Rob Gronovius Visit my motor pool in the

formatting link
gallery

Reply to
Rob Gronovius

I read in last week's TIME magazine that the Bush Regime is kicking around privatizing a lot of non-combat military functions. So, maybe they'll have illegal immigrants employed by Hallibechtel doing the bugling. Taps with a mariachi beat, anyone? Kim M

Operation American Freedom-Where is our regime change?

Reply to
Royabulgaf

When I was in the Navy, I witnessed a really sorry burial at sea for a few dozen veterans' ashes. I was part of the honor guard on the main deck, and what did I hear playing Taps over the 1MC loudspeaker?

A HARMONICA!!!

I guess our dufus exec couldn't scare up a decent recording, so he whips out his trusty old mouth harp and has at it.

Doesn't help that the idiot then proceeded to scatter the ashes off the bridge wing, allowing the wind to carry the dear departed's remains over the main deck and...you guessed it...over the assembled crew in their dress whites. You could see guys flinching and trying their hardest not to inhale the ashes of their brothers-in-arms.

The spirit of solemnity and respect for the occasion was there, but the execution left a lot to be desired.

Reply to
Michael Alvarez

Tell me about it!

That was what was done when I buried my father at Alrington.

Jonathan Primm snipped-for-privacy@aol.com

Reply to
JP5844

My condolensces. But you put him in a good place, and it sounds like you sent him out in style.

Reply to
Scott Lowther

Reply to
Grandpa

Reply to
Grandpa

Rifles? RIFLES?!?! What, are you INSANE??? Think of the *children,* man!

Reply to
Scott Lowther

I had a friend who was a bugler for the 3rd Army Band. At the height of the Vietnam War he blew taps at dozens of funerals, so many that his lips finally burst and he was medically discharged. All the way to his death he felt he should have got ' A Purple Heart for my Purple Lips' but took it in stride as the sacrifice to honored dead. Mike IPMS

Reply to
Mike Keown

I'll echo your sentiment - and add that the only thing I've ever experienced at a service that's more moving is a missing-man overflight.

Especially when you know (knew) the guy that's missing...

Reply to
Rufus

Most (if not all) funerals with military honors that I've attended have had a rifle squad present for salute during the ceremony at graveside.

I helped police the brass for the last squad of Marines that honored a friend of mine. The Corp sent a genuine live Marine bugler, too. The way it SHOULD be.

Reply to
Rufus

the three day non stop black and white afn nurnburg broadcast of jfk's funeral is about as haunted as i'll ever get. i found some 7" reel tapse i made. incredibly different universe to be in for a while via plastic tape.

Reply to
e

Not at all! Its just the fallen heroes accepting another comrade to their ranks.

-- John ___ __[xxx]__ (o - ) --------o00o--(_)--o00o-------

The history of things that didn't happen has never been written - Henry Kissinger

Reply to
The Old Timer

My Dada died in 1984, a retired RADM USNR. He had requested double buglers, so I called both the Boston and Newport Naval Stations ... they laughed at me. The funeral director called our US senator and we ended up with two honor guards!

Here in San Diego veterans have now taken over that chore. Al Fisher snipped-for-privacy@aol.com

Reply to
AFisherJr

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.