Is old book any good?

Dec 02, 2010 20 Replies

Hi, bought some old 'Model Railway News' mags: May 1970: "British Goods Wagons From 1887 To The Present Day" R.J.Essery, D.P.Rowland and W.O.Steel. The review looks excellent. Does anyone know this book? Is it worth chasing to find a copy? Is the same material covered better in more recent books?



Regards, Greg.P. NZ


In its day, Essery's book was 'the bible' for the keen modeller of goods wagons.

Never seen any poor book with his name on it. Rowland is another good author. Depends what you are interested in. If its LMS then recommend The LMS Wagon by Essery and Morgan, quite a modest size but packed with excellent info. If Midland then Midland Wagons by Essery, volume 1 and 2 - think either one or both has recently been reprinted.

CHeers, Simon

Keep in mind that 'Present Day' day means late 1960s.

So it'll be pretty good for private owner wagons for the preceding 50 years or so.

So who nabbed the reasonably price copy on Amazon? Only the silly money copies left now :(

Lots of copies on

formatting link
Use keyword railways, cut'n'paste the title.

Creeping up to silly prices ;) The copy on Amazon was £19 ... but £25 is not too bad, and I can show SHMBO the £120 price on Amazon and say it's an investment :)

That's ok, I haven't progressed beyond the 1960s.

But some of the best music came out in the 70's and 80's.

I'd have bought it at the reasonable price but not at the silly money prices! I will put it on my list of books to check every once in a while.

Dunno, when was 'West Of The Wall'?

Unfortunately not known, now Jethro Tull ....

OK, so I did briefly wander into the 70s, musically.

80s was that stupid pointing at the lights, pointing at your crotch dancing stuff and I had children and a layout to raise. The 60 was the proper music era, although I was in a band in the late 60s and missed the odd year or two.

Always worth phoning Robert Humm

formatting link

The Agriculturist? Well before my time.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required