Hi Guys,
I've known about this product for some time, and quite nice it is too,
however I personally don't like the uniformity, I prefer randomness.
It's good if you can't make your own billets, or you want exactly the
same knife/item.
Regards Charles
P.S. You pay for it ;-)
John O. K>
Never thought of using stainless steel tools for forging, would have
thought it would be too brittle? :-\
Would you use the Damasteel, seeing it's for the wasted steel method,
forging the stuff would screw the pattern.
What do you prefer random or uniform patterns?
Charles
Seems to me that brittle would depend on the heat treatment more than the
content. I didn't really look at the site all that much, as I make my own. I
can't see how using a tool would screw up the pattern all that much, unless
you had internal flaws that would cause delamination in use. Every pattern
is 'random', even if you try to get repeats. As long as you hammer you're
going to get variance in the finished piece. Each stroke moves the metal
around, and unless you use a robot you're never going to hit the work
exactly the same twice. You can plan for tendencies, but in the end it's
still a crapshoot. But that's part of the fun. Sometimes you get pictures. I
had a bud that made a billet that had shamrocks running down the length;
he's Irish. I had another bud whose billet had a wolfpack in it, he's a
Biker. I've had dragons, Dwarves, mountain ranges, all kinds of stuff show
up in the finished work. Magick, I tell ya. Magick. Maybe those olde stories
about magic weapons aren't so far off after all. Fire is a Live Thing; blood
and sweat get hammered into the billet during forging. Stranger things have
happened, you've just got to be open to things.
Charly
I'm generally a pretty skeptical of "mystical phenomena," but I could
swear sometimes a piece of stock just somehow _wants_ to be a specific
item, pattern, etc. And -- sometimes, no matter how hard you try, you
just _can't_ duplicate a certain piece, even if you made the first one 2
minutes ago, until you settle down and just let it happen. (sometimes
not even then. :)
It's a weird feeling, with no known explanation AFAIK.
I know exactly what you mean. It's not all science, there's art too, sometimes
'black art'. I'm not advocating flowing robes and a pointy hat, but there are
strange things in the universe that flat defy the 'immutable Laws of Science as
we
know them'. What a dull place this would be without the wonder of creative
accidents. It's that possibility that keeps me going out to the fire and swinging
the hammer. What's going to reveal itself this time?
Charly
Charly,
You've rediscovered, for yourself, why Smiths had their own god -
Vulcan - and their works were considered more arcane than those of the
Alchemists and Wizards of their day.
I've long suspected that there was as much telekenesis as hammering
involved in both smithing and sculpture. [The main difference is the
material which has, in side it, some thing.]
Sort of like staring at clouds or drill injuries, with clouds you can
see lots of things (more so when you've had a few ;-) ), with the scar
on my left pointer I can swear it's shaped like a little man :-D
Regards Charles
The damasteel billets are incredibly uniform, take some time to look at
the site and you'll see this. I was saying that forging a piece of
damasteel bar stock would screw the uniformity that their product is
known for.
I'm not sure how they achieve this, unless they have a computer involved
somewhere in the manufacturing process.
I make my own billets also, and like how no two blades are the same,
sort of why I haven't use the damasteel product.
As far as magick is concerned it's like sh*t... Magick happens :-)
Regards Charles
Hi Charly,
I'm glad it's not all science, it'd be really boring. Oh and why not
suggest flowing robes and a pointy hat? Funnily enough there is a guy
on the net somewhere that does just that... just goes to show standards
in safety equipment differ a bit :-)
The one that blows me away is that copper takes a certain temperature to
melt, however if you add a little tin the melt point lowers
dramatically. If you had never done casting before you would logically
assume the melt point would remain the same, but this is not the case...
weird... 42 :-)
The surprises keep me playing also ;-)
Regards Charles
Vulcan??? (live long and prosper :-p ) Heretic!
Hephaestus made much better gear, come on forging lightning bolts can't
be an easy job :-)
Regards Charles
They probably use presses or a rolling mill. Hammering would take too much time
in
production. It's most likely a continuous process setup; stock goes in one end,
billet
comes out the other. Chop to length, sell on the internet. It would certainly be
easy
enough; feed the stock, manipulate the pattern cold, induction heat in inert
atmosphere,
run through the roller to weld it, allow to cool, cut to length. Fast, clean,
effecient,
BORING. I'll stick to my hammer, thanks anyway.
Charly
I hope they're made of nomex, I've set my clothes on fire more than once from
slag
splatters. I don't even want to think about the entanglement issue; the
powerhammer can
be a nasty dancing partner.
The gent concerned seems to use a bonfire to forge his swords, and has a
musician playing in the background... well from the pics on his site it
seems this is the case, although it may just be an elaborate show... it
guess.
Regards Charles
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.